I like Dolph.
I remember reading guys raving about how he was making the IC title relevant again, but now he's somehow deplorable.
The guy is an upper mid-carder at his peak. I've always conceded that as a fan of his.
He was arguably the most over guy on the roster after Survivor Series, but they shortly "fired" him afterwards & removed him off of television.
Dolph is the guy who isn't a consistent main eventer, but you can stick him in a main event and he doesn't look out of place.
I'd even say he'd be worthy of a transitional title run with the right angle.
He always makes his opponents look terrific and could be the stepping stone for guys transitioning from the midcard to the main event
His biggest hurdle is his booking & his mouth.
He doesn't know when to shut up and his booking almost always goes to the dumps when he gains significant momentum.
Dolph would be among the two or three guys I'd build my upper midcard around.
Edit: I'll also say that while I like Dolph, I think the thing keeping him from the main event scene more than his offense or psychology is the fact he doesn't have a character.
He's arrogant, "steals the show" & "shows off."
Thats cool and lays the foundation for a character, but who are you, dude?