At this point in their careers Reigns or Rollins?

[Dipsey Doo]

Seth got the Visionary gimmick so over, it turned him babyface organically

Roman needed COVID, Paul Heyman, Sami Zayn and his cousins to get his current gimmick to this point

Seth lost to Cody Rhodes three times and is more over now then he was a year ago

Roman hasn't eaten a pin since 2019, and the wrestlers he beat haven't gotten any sort of rub just from being in a program with him.

Seth got booed out the building with the Beast Slayer gimmick and turned it into the Monday Night Messiah gimmick which was gold

Only cancer could stop Roman Reigns from getting booed.

Seth had one of the most memorable and shocking Wrestlemania moments ever.

I can't remember an actual good Roman Reigns Wrestlemania main event.

I can't believe this poll is this lopsided.

 

[OGBobbyJohnson]

 

[Tres Leches]

rollins just swagger jacked the joker



he is doing a good job at it though



did we forget when he had that stupid turn with aop ?

 

[ALonelyDad]

Roman's aura is so big now that he just feels like the bigger fighter/name.

In terms of wrestling alone, it is Rollins. Hopefully Rollins can get another main title run in the future, he has done nothing but be a company man these last 2 years

 

[WaveMolecules]

rollins is the better pro wrestler.
reigns is the better sports entertainer.

 

[HollywoodP]

Reigns is better. You can say that ring work shyt vs mic work and entertainment all you want but all that shyt is part of being a pro wrestler...all of it. Especially in WWE. Roman has figured it out. Thats why they put him in the main event of everything. He elevates everyone around him. Usos and Heyman who were already GOATed. Sami, Pearce, Owens... Thats why he gets the long segments, the backstage segments, the opening segments, the closing segments. Thats why hes on Smackdown and Raw. Thats why he has both belts. I wouldnt say Seth has more dope matches than Roman either. Its Roman easy.

 

[African_brehda]

Roman has figured it out. Thats why they put him in the main event of everything. He elevates everyone around him. Usos and Heyman who were already GOATed. Sami, Pearce, Owens... Thats why he gets the long segments, the backstage segments, the opening segments, the closing segments. Thats why hes on Smackdown and Raw

You talk like it’s up to him. He has been literally handpicked and booked to be that person. Telling us he’s figured it out when they were booing him out of arenas for 4 years straight

 

[African_brehda]

Roman's aura is so big now that he just feels like the bigger fighter/name.

In terms of wrestling alone, it is Rollins. Hopefully Rollins can get another main title run in the future, he has done nothing but be a company man these last 2 years

Another championship run won’t do much imo. What I feel he lacks now is a career defining storyline or angle. But those are usually reserved for the top guy.

His best bet is them finally booking a long term between him and Roman

 

[White City Black]

Another championship run won’t do much imo. What I feel he lacks now is a career defining storyline or angle. But those are usually reserved for the top guy.

His best bet is them finally booking a long term between him and Roman

If they were truly into the idea of putting one of the top belts back on Rollins, they’d do a full circle Rollins where, while nodding to all of his different character arcs, he becomes focused and serious about finally dethroning Reigns.

Just imagining the build and that “MyWay” type video package showing their career trajectories and how this has to happen one more time

 

[Norrin Radd]

A Rollins vs Reigns feud could be the next big thing (arguably as entertaining as The Bloodline/Sami) if they do it right

 

[African_brehda]

If they were truly into the idea of putting one of the top belts back on Rollins, they’d do a full circle Rollins where, while nodding to all of his different character arcs, he becomes focused and serious about finally dethroning Reigns.

Just imagining the build and that “MyWay” type video package showing their career trajectories and how this has to happen one more time

That could even be a wrestlemania main event. But it’s highly unlikely. Since Shawn Michaels vs Undertaker, I don’t think there has been a male main event between wrestlers from the same era

 

[NotAnFBIagent]

Reigns washing Rollins in here.
This tribal chief run has rejuvenated his career.

 

[Dipsey Doo]

If anyone voted for Reigns, I don't take you as a serious wrestling head. You don't know what you're talking about at all.

TSC exposing themselves badly in this thread by selecting stiff azz Roman Reigns

 

[TOAD99]

They’re honestly both great in their own respective ways

Rollins has gotten all of his gimmicks over and is constantly reinventing himself and puts on great matches all the time

Reigns is on a legendary run and has finally found his character and has good segments and promos. He also feels like a big time prize fighter when he defends the belt

I honestly would like to see them have a longer term feud

 

[jadillac]

You talk like it’s up to him. He has been literally handpicked and booked to be that person. Telling us he’s figured it out when they were booing him out of arenas for 4 years straight

This is the type of character Roman should have been building to all along. Not his fault Vince tried to make him Cena pt 2 for several years