Ancestry DNA Matches from Africa - Are These Questions Ok to Ask Them or Nah?

Black Haven

We will find another road to glory!!!
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
3,160
Reputation
928
Daps
13,250
Thanks :smile:

Lots of time, work and research - I have been working on my tree for over 4 years.

On African matches - you can search your matches on Ancestry.

It’s sounds like you need to order your grandparents death certificates - you can’t find them on Ancestry or Family Search?

If you can’t find your paternal grandparents work on your maternal grandparents. And vice-versa.

Were your grandparents born before or after 1940?

What states were they born in?
I found all four of my grandparents on familysearch.org the problem is I'm having trouble getting more info past them and yes they were all born before 1940. To answer your question @im_sleep I only know the states my maternal grandparents were born in which are Mississippi and Illinois respectively. I may have to find all their birth and death certificates to get more info. Also appreciate the offer Dede but, this is something I want to do my self.
 

xoxodede

Superstar
Joined
Aug 6, 2015
Messages
11,054
Reputation
9,240
Daps
51,572
Reppin
Michigan/Atlanta
I found all four of my grandparents on familysearch.org the problem is I'm having trouble getting more info past them and yes they were all born before 1940. To answer your question @im_sleep I only know the states my maternal grandparents were born in which are Mississippi and Illinois respectively. I may have to find all their birth and death certificates to get more info. Also appreciate the offer Dede but, this is something I want to do my self.

You’re welcome! And I totally understand :smile:

Questions/Tips:

-- Did you find them on Census? If so, what year?

-- Who was in the household? Just them or your parent and their siblings?

-- Are they only on one Census?

If so, open Census record document and look through the pages and look at their neighbors and look for the same last names - usually family in the south stayed in/on the same neighborhood/area/road and would be on the same Census - but a few pages over.

Example: Let’s say you are “Jackson” and your grandparents age on the Census is 40 and and 38 —while you browse through the document — two pages over you notice another black Jackson family with a man/woman but they are older 65 and 60 - this could be your Great Grandparents.

Then you search their names (the 60/65 Jackson couple) in FamilySearch —and see if you can find Census record(a) with them on it. Then look to see who is in the household — look for your Grandparent or their siblings name in the household with them.

-- Do you know any of your Grandmothers maiden names? If so, search her first name and her maiden name and search both states.

-- Do/Did your grandparents have siblings? If so, search their names.

Tip: For Great Aunts search their maiden and married name — and for the Great Uncles - their wives (or children’s) first name with your Great Uncles last name — and in those states. You should be able to find marriage records with their parents listed for bride and groom.

Tip: If you know your Grandparents last name - search the county/state with only the last name and look at all and look for matches that share your grandparents name. (Use FamilySearch.Org) it’s free and clearer — and just easier to comb through to me).

Tip: If your Grandparents where buried in Mississippi or Illinois — go to library in those and search newspapers archives in those states and look for their obituary or funeral notice.

If you know the funeral home your family uses or the church your family is buried or attends in that county/state --- call them and ask them if they have a copy of the obituary or funeral service. They often keep a copy on file.

Tip: Sign up for a trial membership or regular Ancestry membership - and build your tree based on just your parents and their parents - it will give you hints or connect you to relatives or potential relatives that share your grandparents - and they often have a tree built.

Honestly, that’s how I got started. Don’t copy their tree info -- but save the names and do the research to verify if they are your Great Grandparents and so on.

I hope this helps! Good luck! And let me know if you run into any issues - I can give you some more tips and/or share free resources that helped me. :smile:

P.S. I really like FamilySearch.Org the best for searches - plus it’s free.
 
Last edited:

im_sleep

Superstar
Joined
Jan 29, 2017
Messages
2,860
Reputation
1,324
Daps
15,231
I found all four of my grandparents on familysearch.org the problem is I'm having trouble getting more info past them and yes they were all born before 1940. To answer your question @im_sleep I only know the states my maternal grandparents were born in which are Mississippi and Illinois respectively. I may have to find all their birth and death certificates to get more info. Also appreciate the offer Dede but, this is something I want to do my self.
Have they died in Illinois?

Try to find out the mortuary who did their service and see if you can find an obituary. I might have to do that myself for some of my family in Chicago.

Mississippi is terrible when it comes to records but Illinois(Cook County at least) is pretty good.
 

Premeditated

MANDE KANG
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
31,451
Reputation
2,504
Daps
92,187
Reppin
IMMIGRANT TETHERS
I don't know if you have a basic knowledge of that region, but here is what I recall. Now this is all from my recollection so it is probably wrong. I may have totally misremembered everything that I am about to write.

From what I remember the Akan people are the Ashanti, Baoule, Brong/Abron, Fante, Denkyira and a few other smaller groups. They are originally from the Kingdom of Ghana in the Sahel, but they (the Akan people) left at some point in the 1300's and retreated into the forest of modern day central Ghana and Ivory Coast; most likely to avoid the spread of Islam that was occurring among the Mande (Sonnike, Mandingos, Bambaran, Susu, etc.), Fulani and Berber ethnic groups in the Sahel. They traded goal mined in the forest belt with the Mande people in the Sahel.

Upon the arrival in the forest belt the Brong where the most dominant of the the Akan group, but over time the Ashanti, Fante, Denkyira, and Baoule became stronger. The Ashanti rose to prominence after defeating the Denkyira. Once the Ashanti rose to power many of the other Akan groups (except for the Fante) fled.

The Baoule fled to the Ivory Coast, wherein they are now the largest ethnic group in that Country, where they are something like 40%-45% of the total population in Ivory Coast. Branches of the Brong that were in Central Ghana, also fled to the Ivory Coast, where I think they are referred to as Abron; but in reality I think that they are still the same as the Brong that live in Ghana.

The parties that did the enslaving and the selling of slaves in Ghana and for that matter Ivory Coast is complicated. From what I can remember reading the Ashanti controlled the slave trade in that region, but they were not actually interested in selling slaves; they were actually only interested in the gold trade but they took slaves as a payment of tribute from groups like the Dagomba people. The Ashanti defeated the Dagomba in warfare and thus subjugated them. The Ashanti requested gold from all people they subjugated, but Dagomba specifically, chose to pay in slaves. The Ashanti in turn would sell those slaves to the Europeans at the coast.

The Dagomba are not an Akan people. I think that they are Gur. They live in Northern Ghana and Southern Burkina Faso and used slave markets at Salaga. I think that the Ga live Ghana and Togo. I don't recall any groups selling their own ethnic groups, but the Ashanti would have likely traded any groups to the Europeans that were given to them by the Dagomba.

Slavery in Northern Ghana


Baoulé people - Wikipedia
Denkyira - Wikipedia

damn, I always wondered why they called it the Kingdom of Ghana. This might explain it.
 

Samori Toure

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 23, 2015
Messages
19,995
Reputation
6,251
Daps
100,200
damn, I always wondered why they called it the Kingdom of Ghana. This might explain it.

Yup the Country of Ghana is named after the Kingdom of Ghana and the Country of Mali is named after the Kingdom of Mali. It has to also be mentioned that when Ghana is mentioned then the Ivory Coast has to also be mentioned.

Right on the website of Ancestry.com they explain of the history of Ivory Coast and Ghana:


Ivory Coast/Ghana

Primarily located in: Ivory Coast, Ghana

Also found in: Benin, Togo, Mali, Nigeria, Senegal

Early French and Portuguese explorers identified sections of the West African coast by the area’s resources, which is how Côte d'Ivoire, or Ivory Coast, got its name. Neighboring Ghana was known as the Gold Coast until it won independence from colonial rule in 1957 and renamed itself after a medieval West African empire. Today, more than 46 million people live in the two countries, which depend less on gold and ivory than they do chocolate: Ivory Coast and Ghana produce more than half of the world’s cocoa.

There is evidence of human activity in the area of modern-day Ivory Coast and Ghana going back millennia. Some groups, such as the Akan, trace their history in the region to at least the 11th century. Historians believe that most current populations were in place by the 16th century after absorbing or displacing previous inhabitants. Ghana and Ivory Coast are each home to more than 60 different ethnic groups today.

img1.png

Geography played an influential role on the populations of Ghana and Ivory Coast. In both countries, the terrain ranges from savanna in the north to forest in the south. The dense forests acted as partial barriers to trade, migration and forming large, centralized societies like those that appeared farther north, where vast empires rose and fell for more than a millennium. The north-south divide is also evident in religion: Islam came to West Africa with the trans-Saharan trade and is more prevalent in the north; Christianity, introduced by Europeans, gained a foothold in the south.

img2.jpg

A woman walks through dense forests in central Ghana
Migrations into Ivory Coast and Ghana
Modern Ivory Coast and Ghana lie on the periphery of the great empires of Mali (ca. 1230–1550) and Songhai (ca. 1375–1591), and the region’s population felt their influence. As empires rose and fell, people pushed into new lands or fled old ones. Dyula (or Juula) traders, a merchant class of Mandé people from Mali, made their way south, introducing goods, inhabitants and Islam to the northern edges of modern-day Ghana. They later established the Kong Empire (1710–1898) in northeastern Ivory Coast. Other Mandé groups settled in western Ivory Coast, where they make up almost 25% of the population today.

According to their own oral tradition, the Dagomba people came from the area northeast of Lake Chad, finally settling in northern Ghana. The Senufo came south from Mali into Ivory Coast in about the 15th century. The Ewe people migrated from the east, from the areas now making up Togo and Benin.

The most significant migration for Ghana and Ivory Coast, however, began with the arrival of the Akan people. The Akan had established the state of Bonoman—a center of trade for gold, salt, kola nuts, ivory and leather—in western Ghana/eastern Ivory Coast. From Bonoman, they spread out looking for gold.

The Akan people
With a population of 20 million, the Akan represent the largest ethnic group in Ghana and Ivory Coast. The Akan are a matrilineal society believed to have originated in the Sahel region and who then traveled south into Ghana and Ivory Coast.

The Ashanti, a subgroup of the Akan, formed a number of states in Ghana built around trade and gold. They traded with the Songhai and Hausa along traditional inland routes and also with European partners, starting with the Portuguese, who arrived on the coast in 1482. New crops, such as maize and cassava, and slave labor allowed them to push farther into the forests, clearing land to farm and mining gold. In fact, before the transatlantic slave trade began in earnest, the Ashanti bought slaves from the Portuguese.

The Ashanti Empire was established in 1701 by Osei Tutu, who began unifying Ashanti states around the city of Kumasi. The Ashanti continued to expand, through diplomacy and military conquest, building one of the most advanced and powerful empires in sub-Saharan Africa. Not all Akan people wanted part in the empire, and some fled west into modern-day Ivory Coast. These included the Abron, the Baoulé and the Agni. In the 19th century, the Ashanti fought a series of wars with British troops, as England tried to firm up its hold over Ghana. Eventually, the Ashanti kingdom, known as Asanteman, became a British protectorate in 1902 and today is a state within modern Ghana.

img3.jpg

Defeat of the Ashantis by British forces, July 11, 1824
French sovereignty over Ivory Coast was recognized by the British in 1889, and the country became a French colony in 1893. Ivory Coast continued to attract new immigrants in the 20th century when two decades of prosperity and relative peace followed independence in 1960.

Please note that genetic ethnicity estimates are based on individuals living in this region today. While a prediction of genetic ethnicity from this region suggests a connection to the groups occupying this location, it is not conclusive evidence of membership to any particular tribe or ethnic group.

Did You Know?
The Ashanti had their own telegraph long before American inventor Samuel Morse patented his (in 1847). The Ashanti people sent messages through the forest via drum. The tones of their famous “talking drums” mimic their own tonal language.

img4.jpg

Ashanti drummer with talking drums
 

Samori Toure

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 23, 2015
Messages
19,995
Reputation
6,251
Daps
100,200
23andMe is beginning to do a much better job in genealogy portion of their database. They had previously stated on my DNA timeline:

Your Ancestry Timeline

"You most likely had a grandparent, great-grandparent, or second-great-grandparent who was 100% West African. This person was likely born between 1850 and 1910."

23andMe then recently upgraded an Ancestry Composition chart for me to say the following:

Ghana
We predict you had ancestors that lived in Ghana within the last 200 years.


That is a pretty amazing stuff, because slavery ended in the USA 153 years ago and I no doubt still must have lots of living relatives in Ghana and Ivory Coast.

Crazy stuff.
 
Last edited:

xoxodede

Superstar
Joined
Aug 6, 2015
Messages
11,054
Reputation
9,240
Daps
51,572
Reppin
Michigan/Atlanta
Yup the Country of Ghana is named after the Kingdom of Ghana and the Country of Mali is named after the Kingdom of Mali. It has to also be mentioned that when Ghana is mentioned then the Ivory Coast has to also be mentioned.

Right on the website of Ancestry.com they explain of the history of Ivory Coast and Ghana:


Ivory Coast/Ghana

Primarily located in: Ivory Coast, Ghana

Also found in: Benin, Togo, Mali, Nigeria, Senegal

Early French and Portuguese explorers identified sections of the West African coast by the area’s resources, which is how Côte d'Ivoire, or Ivory Coast, got its name. Neighboring Ghana was known as the Gold Coast until it won independence from colonial rule in 1957 and renamed itself after a medieval West African empire. Today, more than 46 million people live in the two countries, which depend less on gold and ivory than they do chocolate: Ivory Coast and Ghana produce more than half of the world’s cocoa.

There is evidence of human activity in the area of modern-day Ivory Coast and Ghana going back millennia. Some groups, such as the Akan, trace their history in the region to at least the 11th century. Historians believe that most current populations were in place by the 16th century after absorbing or displacing previous inhabitants. Ghana and Ivory Coast are each home to more than 60 different ethnic groups today.

img1.png

Geography played an influential role on the populations of Ghana and Ivory Coast. In both countries, the terrain ranges from savanna in the north to forest in the south. The dense forests acted as partial barriers to trade, migration and forming large, centralized societies like those that appeared farther north, where vast empires rose and fell for more than a millennium. The north-south divide is also evident in religion: Islam came to West Africa with the trans-Saharan trade and is more prevalent in the north; Christianity, introduced by Europeans, gained a foothold in the south.

img2.jpg

A woman walks through dense forests in central Ghana
Migrations into Ivory Coast and Ghana
Modern Ivory Coast and Ghana lie on the periphery of the great empires of Mali (ca. 1230–1550) and Songhai (ca. 1375–1591), and the region’s population felt their influence. As empires rose and fell, people pushed into new lands or fled old ones. Dyula (or Juula) traders, a merchant class of Mandé people from Mali, made their way south, introducing goods, inhabitants and Islam to the northern edges of modern-day Ghana. They later established the Kong Empire (1710–1898) in northeastern Ivory Coast. Other Mandé groups settled in western Ivory Coast, where they make up almost 25% of the population today.

According to their own oral tradition, the Dagomba people came from the area northeast of Lake Chad, finally settling in northern Ghana. The Senufo came south from Mali into Ivory Coast in about the 15th century. The Ewe people migrated from the east, from the areas now making up Togo and Benin.

The most significant migration for Ghana and Ivory Coast, however, began with the arrival of the Akan people. The Akan had established the state of Bonoman—a center of trade for gold, salt, kola nuts, ivory and leather—in western Ghana/eastern Ivory Coast. From Bonoman, they spread out looking for gold.

The Akan people
With a population of 20 million, the Akan represent the largest ethnic group in Ghana and Ivory Coast. The Akan are a matrilineal society believed to have originated in the Sahel region and who then traveled south into Ghana and Ivory Coast.

The Ashanti, a subgroup of the Akan, formed a number of states in Ghana built around trade and gold. They traded with the Songhai and Hausa along traditional inland routes and also with European partners, starting with the Portuguese, who arrived on the coast in 1482. New crops, such as maize and cassava, and slave labor allowed them to push farther into the forests, clearing land to farm and mining gold. In fact, before the transatlantic slave trade began in earnest, the Ashanti bought slaves from the Portuguese.

The Ashanti Empire was established in 1701 by Osei Tutu, who began unifying Ashanti states around the city of Kumasi. The Ashanti continued to expand, through diplomacy and military conquest, building one of the most advanced and powerful empires in sub-Saharan Africa. Not all Akan people wanted part in the empire, and some fled west into modern-day Ivory Coast. These included the Abron, the Baoulé and the Agni. In the 19th century, the Ashanti fought a series of wars with British troops, as England tried to firm up its hold over Ghana. Eventually, the Ashanti kingdom, known as Asanteman, became a British protectorate in 1902 and today is a state within modern Ghana.

img3.jpg

Defeat of the Ashantis by British forces, July 11, 1824
French sovereignty over Ivory Coast was recognized by the British in 1889, and the country became a French colony in 1893. Ivory Coast continued to attract new immigrants in the 20th century when two decades of prosperity and relative peace followed independence in 1960.

Please note that genetic ethnicity estimates are based on individuals living in this region today. While a prediction of genetic ethnicity from this region suggests a connection to the groups occupying this location, it is not conclusive evidence of membership to any particular tribe or ethnic group.

Did You Know?
The Ashanti had their own telegraph long before American inventor Samuel Morse patented his (in 1847). The Ashanti people sent messages through the forest via drum. The tones of their famous “talking drums” mimic their own tonal language.

img4.jpg

Ashanti drummer with talking drums

This is even more interesting. They were mostly taken/sold from the same area then.

My top three countries are Benin/Togo (19%) Cameroon/Congo (17%) Ghana and Mali (16%)
 

xoxodede

Superstar
Joined
Aug 6, 2015
Messages
11,054
Reputation
9,240
Daps
51,572
Reppin
Michigan/Atlanta
23andMe is beginning to do a much better job in genealogy portion of their database. They had previously stated on my DNA timeline:

Your Ancestry Timeline

"You most likely had a grandparent, great-grandparent, or second-great-grandparent who was 100% West African. This person was likely born between 1850 and 1910."

23andMe then recently upgraded an Ancestry Composition chart for me to say the following:

Ghana
We predict you had ancestors that lived in Ghana within the last 200 years.


That is a pretty amazing stuff, because slavery ended in the USA 153 years ago and I no doubt still must have lots of living relatives in Ghana and Ivory Coast.

Crazy stuff.

They had a sell today - I got my mom, my brother and I one. I’m excited to take it.
 

xoxodede

Superstar
Joined
Aug 6, 2015
Messages
11,054
Reputation
9,240
Daps
51,572
Reppin
Michigan/Atlanta
23andMe is beginning to do a much better job in genealogy portion of their database. They had previously stated on my DNA timeline:

Your Ancestry Timeline

"You most likely had a grandparent, great-grandparent, or second-great-grandparent who was 100% West African. This person was likely born between 1850 and 1910."

23andMe then recently upgraded an Ancestry Composition chart for me to say the following:

Ghana
We predict you had ancestors that lived in Ghana within the last 200 years.


That is a pretty amazing stuff, because slavery ended in the USA 153 years ago and I no doubt still must have lots of living relatives in Ghana and Ivory Coast.

Crazy stuff.

@Akan I need your help again - if you don't mind and whenever you have time. I know you are great with DNA results. :smile:

Yesterday - I uploaded my Ancestry DNA Raw Data to 23andMe - as they had a special for 4 free reports. And I just got my results this AM. Now, I am kinda confused. As I have different results than Ancestry.

Ancestry DNA: 83% SS African

9PsreCp.png


23&Me: 80.2% SS African

Nn3pK5l.png


Y2w2XHy.png


A8abEHR.png


23andMe does seem more comprehensive than Ancestry DNA - but Cabo Verde and Liberia threw me off.

Questions:

-- 23&Me doesn't show Mali and Benin/Togo like AncestryDNA. Would those two countries tie into Ghana and Nigeria with 23andMe - as you explained yesterday about
the Migrations into Ivory Coast and Ghana?

Or

-- Would my Ancestry DNA Mali and Benin/Togo be translated to my Capo Verde on 23&Me? See:Cape Verdean Results

-- How does Liberia come into play? Could it be due to Capo-Verde? Or does it just mean I share DNA markers with natives in the area/country that became known as Liberia?
The Pepper Coast, also known as the Grain Coast, has been inhabited by indigenous peoples of Africa at least as far back as the 12th century. Mende-speaking people expanded westward from the Sudan, forcing many smaller ethnic groups southward toward the Atlantic Ocean. The Dei, Bassa, Kru, Gola and Kissi were some of the earliest documented peoples in the area.[15]

This influx of these groups was compounded by the decline of the Western Sudanic Mali Empire in 1375 and the Songhai Empire in 1591. Liberia was a part of the Kingdom of Koya from 1450 to 1898. As inland regions underwent desertification, inhabitants moved to the wetter coast. These new inhabitants brought skills such as cotton spinning, cloth weaving, iron smelting, rice and sorghum cultivation, and social and political institutions from the Mali and Songhai empires.[15] Shortly after the Mane conquered the region, the Vai people of the former Mali Empire immigrated into the Grand Cape Mount County region. The ethnic Kru opposed the influx of Vai, forming an alliance with the Mane to stop further influx of Vai.[16]

People along the coast built canoes and traded with other West Africans from Cap-Vert to the Gold Coast. Arab traders entered the region from the north, and a long-established slave trade took captives to north and east Africa.
Liberia - Wikipedia
 

Skooby

Alone In My Zone
Supporter
Joined
Sep 30, 2012
Messages
25,218
Reputation
10,267
Daps
59,784
Reppin
The Cosmos
23andMe is beginning to do a much better job in genealogy portion of their database. They had previously stated on my DNA timeline:

Your Ancestry Timeline

"You most likely had a grandparent, great-grandparent, or second-great-grandparent who was 100% West African. This person was likely born between 1850 and 1910."

23andMe then recently upgraded an Ancestry Composition chart for me to say the following:

Ghana
We predict you had ancestors that lived in Ghana within the last 200 years.


That is a pretty amazing stuff, because slavery ended in the USA 153 years ago and I no doubt still must have lots of living relatives in Ghana and Ivory Coast.

Crazy stuff.
Where did you find this on 23andme?
 

Samori Toure

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 23, 2015
Messages
19,995
Reputation
6,251
Daps
100,200
Where did you find this on 23andme?

When you open your account go to:
1. Ancestry Reports;
2. Ancestry Composition;
3. Under Sub-Saharan African you should see the Country that they assign you to.
4. Click on the Country.
5. Scroll down and look at your timeline and click on you West African timeline and they will tell you about your most recent African ancestor that was 100% African. They will give you an estimation of when he or she was born and the relationship that they have to you (Grandparent, Great-Grandparent, Great-Great Grandparent). They are just giving an approximation, but it should be fairly accurate.


I don't know if you are interested in what the backstory might be for why 23andMe is getting so good. If you are not then stop reading now, but if you are then here is the story. They are basically a medical research company, but somehow they got into this business of using DNA to track ancestry. It must be pretty lucrative, because they have really expanded their database in that area. It used to be that they would just say that you were from a region, but AncestryDNA messed up the game by assigning specific countries/regions and percentages. So 23andMe must have felt the need to upgrade their materials to stay competitive.

A couple of years ago 23andMe started giving out free DNA sample kits to Africans, in order to increase their genetic database for people of African descent.
23andMe: African Genetics

In February 2018; 23andMe announced that they had expanded the scope of the regions for Ancestry Composition. It has been a very slow roll out, but they first applied the new regions to newest purchasers and lately they have been applying the regions to their older customers.
23andMe Expands Ancestry Composition With Another 120 Regions - 23andMe Blog

Some of the newest regions added for people of African descent are:

Sub-Saharan African

West African
  • Cabo Verde
  • Cameroon
  • Ghana
  • Liberia
  • Nigeria
East African
  • Eritrea
  • Ethiopia
  • Kenya
  • Somalia
  • Sudan
African Hunter-Gatherer

Broadly Sub-Saharan African

From what I can determine the roll out is probably still going on, because so far 23andMe has only assigned me to the Country of Ghana. I know from testing with AncestryDNA that I should have more countries assigned to me, because over 70% of all of my DNA is from Cameroon/Congo (38%) and Ivory Coast/Ghana (32%). So I assume that 23andMe will also be assigning me to Liberia and Cameroon and possible Cabo Verde, which should be a substitute for Senegal which is the Country that Ancestry has.
 

Samori Toure

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 23, 2015
Messages
19,995
Reputation
6,251
Daps
100,200
@Akan I need your help again - if you don't mind and whenever you have time. I know you are great with DNA results. :smile:

Yesterday - I uploaded my Ancestry DNA Raw Data to 23andMe - as they had a special for 4 free reports. And I just got my results this AM. Now, I am kinda confused. As I have different results than Ancestry.

Ancestry DNA: 83% SS African

9PsreCp.png


23&Me: 80.2% SS African

Nn3pK5l.png


Y2w2XHy.png


A8abEHR.png


23andMe does seem more comprehensive than Ancestry DNA - but Cabo Verde and Liberia threw me off.

Questions:

-- 23&Me doesn't show Mali and Benin/Togo like AncestryDNA. Would those two countries tie into Ghana and Nigeria with 23andMe - as you explained yesterday about
the Migrations into Ivory Coast and Ghana?

Or

-- Would my Ancestry DNA Mali and Benin/Togo be translated to my Capo Verde on 23&Me? See:Cape Verdean Results

-- How does Liberia come into play? Could it be due to Capo-Verde? Or does it just mean I share DNA markers with natives in the area/country that became known as Liberia?
The Pepper Coast, also known as the Grain Coast, has been inhabited by indigenous peoples of Africa at least as far back as the 12th century. Mende-speaking people expanded westward from the Sudan, forcing many smaller ethnic groups southward toward the Atlantic Ocean. The Dei, Bassa, Kru, Gola and Kissi were some of the earliest documented peoples in the area.[15]

This influx of these groups was compounded by the decline of the Western Sudanic Mali Empire in 1375 and the Songhai Empire in 1591. Liberia was a part of the Kingdom of Koya from 1450 to 1898. As inland regions underwent desertification, inhabitants moved to the wetter coast. These new inhabitants brought skills such as cotton spinning, cloth weaving, iron smelting, rice and sorghum cultivation, and social and political institutions from the Mali and Songhai empires.[15] Shortly after the Mane conquered the region, the Vai people of the former Mali Empire immigrated into the Grand Cape Mount County region. The ethnic Kru opposed the influx of Vai, forming an alliance with the Mane to stop further influx of Vai.[16]

People along the coast built canoes and traded with other West Africans from Cap-Vert to the Gold Coast. Arab traders entered the region from the north, and a long-established slave trade took captives to north and east Africa.
Liberia - Wikipedia

The first thing that you need to know is that AncestyDNA's database is much, much deeper than 23andMe's. So Ancestry test results are probably more accurate.

Second of all you can not take the countries on these DNA test literally. The results are really for regions, rather than Countries. The significance of that is that Africans lived in Kingdoms, but when the Europeans colonized Africa and created Countries the lines of the Countries cut across Kingdoms. So you have to think about these test results in terms of region rather than Countries. So getting a high result for Ivory Coast/Ghana will mean that you not only have DNA in Ivory Coast and Ghana, but you also will have DNA in Liberia, Sierra Leone, Mali, Burkina Faso, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau and Senegal.

AncestryDNA Regions

Liberia and Sierra Leone came into play, because the Mande people went on something called the Mane Invasion into Liberia and Sierra Leone when the Kingdom of Mali went into decline. The Mande people were already in Ivory Coast, Ghana, Niger, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Gambia, Mauritania and Senegal before the Mane Invasion because of the their military, Dyula (Juula or traders) and Marabouts, but that invasion took them into Liberia and Sierra Leone.

Finally, your test results from 23andme has not assigned a region yet. It just shows you the region that are out there. Eventually they will put you in a region like they did for me, which in my case is Ghana.
 
Top