I got Cabin Fever breh
Tomm Breh everything should be back to normal least the Nba is back 
hold me over til I get home .
Alex Smith 4th in QB rating.
- Thread starter JLova
- Start date
Tomm Breh everything should be back to normal least the Nba is back hold me over til I get home .
#3MB are pretty funny .
In a game by game basis it is, but when you look at a season or a career, it's a pretty good stat.
Look at the top 5 and bottom 5 in QB rating and that's a pretty accurate depiction of who is the best and who is the worst that year.
2011
1. Rodgers
2. Brees
3. Brady
4. Romo
5. Stafford
28. Tebow
29. Grossman
30. Bradford
31. Ponder
32. Skelton
Now tell me that's not a pretty damn accurate assessment of the best and worst QB's of 2011 off the top of the head.
Not really because it's not a good measure of the defense's that people go against. the situations, the type of team they're on, the weapons available to them, etc. It just measures statistics that the best QBs tend to pile up. It's correlated but I don't buy it. It's why guys like Romo have some of the highest QB ratings ever. It's why a guy like Stafford was rated so high last year.
Say what you want but QBR and the DVAR/DVOA system used by football outsiders are CLEARLY superior metrics.
yseJ
Empire strikes back
Qbr is a bit better but it has its own problems. Its main ‘feature’ is that it weighs stats according to situation. But it also can be erroneous-qb is down by 3 TDs and makes a comeback, the first TD is counted the least while the last one is weighted the most positively…kinda absurd if you ask me.
Qbs, WRs and DBs are hardest positions toughest to judge by any conventional stats really without knowing routes and schemes. Too many variables.
Qbs, WRs and DBs are hardest positions toughest to judge by any conventional stats really without knowing routes and schemes. Too many variables.
feelosofer
#ninergang
I'd still take:
Vick
Cam
Romo
Rivers
Stafford
Sanchez
and these nikkas are having a bad year. Alex Smith is barely top 15.
This year, not one of these guys is better than Alex Smith, stop it.
Field Marshall Bradley
Veteran
Nope
StreetDawah
Alhamdulillah
Last edited by a moderator:
DeVanteSwing
Flop Champion
plays against the rams and cardinals 4 times a year lol
feelosofer
#ninergang
Both are top 10 defenses though (well the Rams were until the Pats game) and the Cards are ranked 4th in pass defense, you don't watch the games.