After the halfway point of the season, grade the rookie QB's of the NFL.

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,824
Reputation
2,599
Daps
64,565
Reppin
The Yay
You mean the same coach who started his career 24-8 and won a AFC title and led his team to the superbowl

Lets be real Jim Caldwell was a horrible head coach

:heh:

arent you answering your own question here ? football is a team game and if youre attributing team success to one player/staff member...its idiotic
 

Mr swag

We Out Here
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
17,836
Reputation
-1,677
Daps
31,115
Reppin
The Well Respected Uptown,Virginia
I thought he was an over-hyped guy with "skills" who didn't have enough time at the QB position to come in and play well off the jump.

I`m not a big college football fan so I can't say I sifted through hours of game footage or watched him with a fine tooth comb.

The whole situation just didn't look good considering the team he was going to and their weapons, or lack thereof.

He is running the same offense as college. Dude knew the playbook before he even got drafted
 

heisenburrr

Have Fun Staying Poor
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
5,775
Reputation
270
Daps
5,021
You mean the same coach who started his career 24-8 and won a AFC title and led his team to the superbowl

Lets be real Jim Caldwell was a horrible head coach....problem is he most likely has a better recent body of work than your teams does :manny:

Peyton Manning always helping out black folk

his body of work without a hall of fame top 5 QB ever is a 2-14 season
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,824
Reputation
2,599
Daps
64,565
Reppin
The Yay
your point that "any QB" could have gotten more wins than Painter last year? even though Luck also doubled the win totals of 2 vets who had a better team as well?

you made a great point, for me :usure:
so your point is that a horribly washed up kerry collins and bum ass dan orlovsky are worse than andrew luck ? :heh: I would never have guessed that !
 

heisenburrr

Have Fun Staying Poor
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
5,775
Reputation
270
Daps
5,021
your point that "any QB" could have gotten more wins than Painter last year? even though Luck also doubled the win totals of 2 vets who had a better team as well?

you made a great point, for me :usure:

:snoop:

you can't be that fukking dumb, two vets ? :pachaha:
 

heisenburrr

Have Fun Staying Poor
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
5,775
Reputation
270
Daps
5,021
Kerry Collins and Dan Orlovsky aren't vets now? :sitdown:

They both had chances leading a Colts team with more offensive weapons than Luck has now, Garcon, Coliie, Dallas Clark, plus Wayne

Luck has done significantly more with much less

Are you fukking retarded? :aicmon:

What you fail to understand is

RG3, Ryan Tannehill, Russell Wilson, Brandon Weeden, hell Nick fukking Foles

would've performed at a higher level than any of those 3 bum QBs that played for the Colts last year, no matter the weapons so let's not act like Luck is pulling off miracles now

he's a talented QB who's the sole focus of your offense yes but this improvement isn't all on him, hell it's not so hard to improve on a 2-14 season
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,824
Reputation
2,599
Daps
64,565
Reppin
The Yay
Kerry Collins and Dan Orlovsky aren't vets now? :sitdown:

They both had chances leading a Colts team with more offensive weapons than Luck has now, Garcon, Coliie, Dallas Clark, plus Wayne

Luck has done significantly more with much less

Are you fukking retarded? :aicmon:

:snoop:

here Ill throw you a bone here :pachaha:

orlovsky starting 5 games: 82.4 qb rating, 63 completion %, 6.2 y/a, 6 tds ,4 ints

luck though 7 games: 74.6 qb rating, 55.6 completion %, 6.8 y/a, 8tds, 8 ints

since you brought up stats in the first place, wheres the part where luck has done significantly more ?
 

Ghpstface

Kanye West fan
Joined
Nov 2, 2012
Messages
7,863
Reputation
1,505
Daps
21,807
Reppin
Ice Cream Castle
:snoop:

here Ill throw you a bone here :pachaha:

orlovsky starting 5 games: 82.4 qb rating, 63 completion %, 6.2 y/a, 6 tds ,4 ints

luck though 7 games: 74.6 qb rating, 55.6 completion %, 6.8 y/a, 8tds, 8 ints

since you brought up stats in the first place, wheres the part where luck has done significantly more ?

Wins, maybe? :mjpls:
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,824
Reputation
2,599
Daps
64,565
Reppin
The Yay
the stats that you posted that said luck>tannehill, I used the same goddam stats that seem to show orlovsky was better when we both know thats not the case.
 
Top