im a get hate for this and I know it's a classic in many people's eyes but it seems like they took a good premise and stretched it out further than anticipated.
You can tell they cared about The Corner because it was based on a true story. It felt more organic and cohesive.
The Wire on the other hand while trying to have an overall theme with each season simply had too many WTF moments in the plot.
1. They focused way too much on McNulty's character. Watching it again for the first time in 3 years McNulty helped make the show weak.
2. I don't know how Stringer Bell held his title for that long. He made too many dumb decisions. His profile should've been the same as Avon. There was no need for him to be in court with D'Anglelo and Bird.
3. Bird getting convicted on the strength of Omar's testimony was just plain stupid.
4. Too many plot convience moments to ensure the cops prevailed in season 1, 2, and 5. The cops investigative skills were meh at best, including Lester.
5. Prop Joe went through the entire series without getting the same treatment as Barksdale and Stanfield.
6. The show became a full blown parody of itself in season 5.
7. Season 4 was probably the best one mainly because they didn't push much focus on the police.
8. The reason why season 2 is considered the weakest imo is because of the lazy writing and lazy plot.
Overall I think they tried to do too much and kept the show going based on fan support. I can't be mad at that but I know for a fact the creators never intended the show to run that long and it showed.
You can tell they cared about The Corner because it was based on a true story. It felt more organic and cohesive.
The Wire on the other hand while trying to have an overall theme with each season simply had too many WTF moments in the plot.
1. They focused way too much on McNulty's character. Watching it again for the first time in 3 years McNulty helped make the show weak.
2. I don't know how Stringer Bell held his title for that long. He made too many dumb decisions. His profile should've been the same as Avon. There was no need for him to be in court with D'Anglelo and Bird.
3. Bird getting convicted on the strength of Omar's testimony was just plain stupid.
4. Too many plot convience moments to ensure the cops prevailed in season 1, 2, and 5. The cops investigative skills were meh at best, including Lester.
5. Prop Joe went through the entire series without getting the same treatment as Barksdale and Stanfield.
6. The show became a full blown parody of itself in season 5.
7. Season 4 was probably the best one mainly because they didn't push much focus on the police.
8. The reason why season 2 is considered the weakest imo is because of the lazy writing and lazy plot.
Overall I think they tried to do too much and kept the show going based on fan support. I can't be mad at that but I know for a fact the creators never intended the show to run that long and it showed.