Aaron Rodgers Is Already The GOAT. There Are No Arguments To Be Made Against It.

[Bboystyle]

@Basaglia
And i can tell your a casual or cac nerd because wins arent a solo effort. Its a team effort. To place wins on a qb is dumb as fukk. No qb has ever won anything by themselves. Patriots are clearly a better team then 90% of the nfl. Its why brady has so many wins. If brady was on the browns or some other shyt team, u think hed have rings and come back wins? Hell no.

 

[Basaglia]

@Basaglia
And i can tell your a casual or cac nerd because wins arent a solo effort. I

Man, shut the fukk up. He got one ring.

 

[FabTrey]

Man, shut the fukk up. He got one ring.

that's the end of the debate yall


/thread

 

[Bboystyle]

Man, shut the fukk up. He got one ring.

So what? Brady wouldnt have 5 rings on any other team. Dude got carried by his D and kicker for 3 of them.


But keep being a casual thinking wins is all on the qb

 

[Goat poster]

Rodgers is just

Most talented QB to ever play.

 

[Rekkapryde]

If it's tom's scheme, can you tell me why other QBs have had success and won in new england when brady has been injured or suspended?

Can you tell me why when manning missed all of 2011 the colts went 2-14? Wouldn't that mean that's manning scheme only works with him?

Can you tell me what greenbay's record is in games aaron rodgers does not suit up in and or play?

And trust me GB will flop out of the playoffs this year and it won't have anything to do with receivers. It will once again be the defense which has given up 51, 37, 45, and 44 points in 4 of rodgers playoff losses.

Their defense is atrocious indeed. McCarthy should have bushed Dom Capers years ago

Conversely it was the Pats defense that was boss the first three rings. Weird.

 

[Walt]

Man, shut the fukk up. He got one ring.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Man, I legit thought about you when he went out, and how your agenda was getting some quality wind for its sails.... then he came out the locker room and did the damn thing. But I was guessing you had some good material ready if GB lost that game.

 

[FAH1223]

Their defense is atrocious indeed. McCarthy should have bushed Dom Capers years ago

Conversely it was the Pats defense that was boss the first three rings. Weird.

Capers should have been bushed after Kaepernick ran all over us in the 2012 playoffs

Our secondary is improved.. the youngsters like King, Jackson, and Alexander are good prospects... Williams being the elder leader like Woodson was for him is invaluable...

Issue is there's no LB depth. Clay is not an OLB anymore, he's an ILB. But Thompson has not drafted LBs well or early at all. That's the biggest hole on defense.

 

[FabTrey]

So what? Brady wouldnt have 5 rings on any other team. Dude got carried by his D and kicker for 3 of them.


But keep being a casual thinking wins is all on the qb

is that you rob parker?

always woulda coulda shoulda


jordan with no ring is vince carter with a fadeaway



5 rings happened. should've been 6 if beli didn't choke against manning in 06. brady would've played rex grossman led bears in the SB.


and if brady had a competent oline would've beaten the broncos. hell he almost beat them even after got hit 20+ times against von miller and brehs. imagine rodgers getting hit 20 times he probably gets carted off twice in 1 game.



keep arguing hypotheticals

 

[FabTrey]

rodgers basically had tom brady moment last night.


do that in the SB against top D. then i'll put him top 3 all time

 

[Rekkapryde]

jordan with no ring is vince carter with a fadeaway

 

[L. Deezy]

No bueno to Rodgers.. never been wowed by him. He good in the 2 min offense. Thats about it

 

[FabTrey]

Matt Cassell went 10-5 in place of Brady and really it was 11-5 but since tom started he got the win. Can you tell me how many time in the nfl history has an 11-5 team missed the playoffs?

I'm still waiting for you to tell me what greenbay's record is in games rodgers doesn't play in? Matt flynn is an example of a broken clock being right twice a day. Can you tell me what he did elsewhere?

So before rodgers signed the biggest contract ever, can you tell me how many marquee big time free agent defensive players the packers used their "Cap room" to sign? Only person i can think of is woodson 10 years ago. Can you tell me why Greenbay never brings in free agents who are good to help rodgers?

Can you also tell me how many times has tom brady's defense given up 30 points in a playoff game compared to rodgers defense.

cassel then took the chiefs to the playoffs threw 27tds only 5ints and was one of the mvp candidate before he got exposed in the playoffs. keep trying.

and jimmy G was 5-0 for niners last year.
and jacoby couldn't score against rex ryan's bills. put up fat 0 points. i guess you can't just plugin anybody to be successful


keep bringing that same old tired argument. it's been debunked to death

 

[ryderldb]

He’s probably one of the most talented qbs ever. Strong arm, accurate, and mobile. He doesn’t have the accolades to be the goat though.

 

[Basaglia]

So what? Brady wouldnt have 5 rings on any other team. Dude got carried by his D and kicker for 3 of them.


But keep being a casual thinking wins is all on the qb

kicker and D ain't got 4 superbowl MVPs