8th Ave to 8 Mile. The Official (3) New York Knicks vs (6) Detroit Pistons 2025 First Round Playoffs Thread

Who ya Got


  • Total voters
    94
  • Poll closed .

RickyGQ

No nikkas!
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
15,888
Reputation
2,117
Daps
58,555
Reppin
NJ
Guess who’s the better shooter out of Tobias Harris and Julius Randle :lolbron:


No thank you.

Pistons need a stretch 4. Not no damn broke j ass Randle.
Want to check those numbers again?

 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
71,387
Reputation
11,999
Daps
251,090
Reppin
206 & 734
Want to check those numbers again?

Plus Tobias fades when it matters

Pistons fans gotta accept, the way we've done it since 1990 ain't it...winning with 1 star at best is not going to work ever again. They need to trade picks and some of the young dudes for a star. The "unc" stimulus package got them here but they need to pivot or they'll have a similar year next year. They should literally be trying to package what they got except case for Giannis or someone. Why was Kat never in discussion for Detroit?

They gotta stop trying to do this the hard way.
 

RickyGQ

No nikkas!
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
15,888
Reputation
2,117
Daps
58,555
Reppin
NJ
Plus Tobias fades when it matters

Pistons fans gotta accept, the way we've done it since 1990 ain't it...winning with 1 star at best is not going to work ever again. They need to trade picks and some of the young dudes for a star. The "unc" stimulus package got them here but they need to pivot or they'll have a similar year next year. They should literally be trying to package what they got except case for Giannis or someone. Why was Kat never in discussion for Detroit?

They gotta stop trying to do this the hard way.

They not ready for THAT yet imo. You do that trade when Cade is entering his prime in 3 or 4 years. Right now, is just getting a reliable second fiddle that can help them compete for the second round and eventually the conference championships.
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
71,387
Reputation
11,999
Daps
251,090
Reppin
206 & 734
They not ready for THAT yet imo. You do that trade when Cade is entering his prime in 3 or 4 years. Right now, is just getting a reliable second fiddle that can help them compete for the second round and eventually the conference championships.
A reliable second fiddle makes them 3 games better than this year. I want to be 12 games better.

This type of settling is what I'm talking about. Ask the Hawks if getting a complementary piece to your young PG is enough.
 

manyfaces

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
9,450
Reputation
1,834
Daps
20,782
Plus Tobias fades when it matters

Pistons fans gotta accept, the way we've done it since 1990 ain't it...winning with 1 star at best is not going to work ever again. They need to trade picks and some of the young dudes for a star. The "unc" stimulus package got them here but they need to pivot or they'll have a similar year next year. They should literally be trying to package what they got except case for Giannis or someone. Why was Kat never in discussion for Detroit?

They gotta stop trying to do this the hard way.
Going for Kat was an all in type of trade when the reality was they had no idea what they really had on their hands after that chaotic Monty season. What's happening now is essentially what Weaver and Monty should have been doing last year. That's just a whole year of discovery and team development wasted, water under the bridge now.

And I don't think any of us think just going with Cade as the single star worthy player is the move. We've all been calling for another team threat. But I still don't think it's time for an all in move yet. Look to add another piece this off-season that's not at a major cost regarding assets. You see what happens with internal growth since our young guys have shown to be talented players. Then you see how things shake out heading to the trade deadline. Most of the vets will be expiring, and you can sort out better with the youth who to keep and who's expendable. No need to fasttrack it. That's how you end up with shyt like Blake Griffin trades.

For those citing examples like the the hawks as team that didn't move fast enough, there are counter examples like Boston and Golden State, who in the face of making hasty decisions to trade guys like Klay and JB, stood pat and let them grow together. Your seeing a similar situation with OKC too. This summer is real important though. We'll find out what Trajan thinks of this core by the moves he makes after these playoffs.
 

eastside313

Superstar
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
18,702
Reputation
1,152
Daps
37,593
Plus Tobias fades when it matters

Pistons fans gotta accept, the way we've done it since 1990 ain't it...winning with 1 star at best is not going to work ever again. They need to trade picks and some of the young dudes for a star. The "unc" stimulus package got them here but they need to pivot or they'll have a similar year next year. They should literally be trying to package what they got except case for Giannis or someone. Why was Kat never in discussion for Detroit?

They gotta stop trying to do this the hard way.

Julius Randle ain’t a star
 

eastside313

Superstar
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
18,702
Reputation
1,152
Daps
37,593

eastside313

Superstar
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
18,702
Reputation
1,152
Daps
37,593
What’s that gotta do with who’s better now?

Right now today if i gotta choose one of them to shoot 3’s im choosing Tobias. And his jumper is broke. The pistons need a 4 that shoot. Those couple assist Randle get, Jaden Ivey can do that.


Remind me what type of player the Knicks threw Randle in the bushes for.
 

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
61,899
Reputation
8,568
Daps
197,279
Reppin
BX, NYC
Meh at Randle. Takes the ball away from Cade and Ivey.

Detroit is better off with someone like Markannen.

I also don’t see why the Pistons would move on from Duren. He’s a manchild (still only 21), he’s a double double machine, and he’s got passing chops.
 
Top