((ReFleXioN)) EteRNaL
RIP MR. SMOKE
I'm talking overall careers. I could overlook a subpar performance here and there when you have other great wins on your resume. You mentioned floyd vs maidana. But we seen Floyd dominate canelo. Seen him dominate coralles.James Toney was only 23 when he fought McCallum bro; far from a HOF'er. His big win right before that was against Nunn where he was being badly outboxed till he turned his lights out (pun intended lol). DLH was the first great fighter Mosley fought but no one questioned his greatness really. Thurman's win against Porter in a championship bout was a clear UD in a fight where he didn't get lit up but stood toe to toe. Porter was clearly in his prime during that period. He made Garcia gunshy till he obviously took his foot off the gas & cruised to a decision bro. I did a quick search & Garcia threw 700 punches against Spence. You know how many he threw against Thurman.........lol......434 That should tell you everything you need to know about how that fight went down; he was gunshy & scared of the counters coming back. And it's not that people were blown away by Thurman. He was a unified champ, took down 2 of the top guys in the division, & did it relatively easy but his inactivity robbed us of seeing him against some of the other guys. We'll definitely have to agee to disagree
What performances of Keith will be remembered like these?....if he had any stellar performances aside from porter and Garcia I could understand. But his entire career he's been underwhelming. Forget his big fights. Even against guys like collazo and josesito he never looked spectacular.
When you look at Keith's entire career, he was nothing more than a B level fighter. His best wins being close decisions over porter and Danny. Two guys who themselves were B level fighters in a very underwhelming welterweight era. These guys are not Mosley and delahoya. They're not even Fernando Vargas. If Keith was gonna show he was truly elite it would have been in those fights. Just like bud did against Spence. But every time Keith had a chance to prove his greatness he always disappointed.