2nd Annual College Football Playoff Rankings Thread

[Buckeye Fever]

I had a feeling the play calling was gonna cost us at some point this season
Maybe our L will force Urb to look into our oc position

Hope so

 

[Illin Degenerate]

he talks about the terrible acc like clemson and florida state haven't been sonning SEC schools for 4 years

since 2012 clemson and fsu have combined beat:

auburn [2x]
LSU
georgia
ohio state
south carolina
oklahoma
Notre dame [2x]
OK st
florida [2x]

but the acc aint shyt

i dont know if i'd put clemson and fsu in the same boat prior to this year. clemson went 1-7 in the regular season vs teams that finished ranked 2012-2014, only win by 6 over no.24 louisville last year at home. their 4 year stretch of at least 10 wins going into this year they lost at least 2 games every year by double digits.

i give dabo credit, hes managed to build up that program into a national title contender while having an atrocious record in the regular season vs good teams the 4 years prior. they have 2 good wins this year, but i think theyll get exposed when they finally face a good team away from home.

 

[jadillac]

I had a feeling the play calling was gonna cost us at some point this season
Maybe our L will force Urb to look into our oc position

Of y'all run a version of the air raid, y'all have the athletes to run away with the conf. Nobody could keep up.

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

This playing out just like last year with the Big 12. Wont surprise me if they get left out again. Better get that chip game. It does matter

Which is contradictory to EVERYTHING they've said since the beginning. The voting by the seat of our pants strategy has stripped them of any legitimacy imo

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

No disrespect to the Alabama fans in here but they keep saying "look at the resume" and not the one loss. My question is what resume? They beat Miss St. Who else did they beat that's good?

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

No disrespect to the Alabama fans in here but they keep saying "look at the resume" and not the one loss. My question is what resume? They beat Miss St. Who else did they beat that's good?

Here we go. THANK YOU

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Man I think some of you are drunk. They aren't leaving out a B1G title winner unless it's Michigan because they have two losses. They aren't leaving out a 1-loss SEC title winner. they aren't leaving out a 1-loss Notre Dame.

Unless some prime fukkery happens the playoff is going to be

Alabama/Florida
Sparty/Iowa/Ohio St.
Notre Dame
Clemson or Oklahoma/Baylor

Oklahoma will need Clemson to lose to UNC or Florida to lose to FSU and then beat Bama or Michigan to win the B1G

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

Alabama:

• Lost AT HOME to 3 loss ole piss
• Beat the same Wisconsin team that Iowa did, so that neutralizes any credit you give the other
• Beat joke squads in middle tn, ul monroe, Charleston southern
• Beat weak ass Georgia and Arkansas (AINT shyt)
• Beat weak ass TN, and aTm, wanna laugh...go see who THEY beat between their 3/4 losses a piece, same with above two
• Beat lsu, later exposed as fukk

So their most impressive wins are an overrated and exposed lsu, and a Wisconsin Iowa also beat...and they lost at home to old piss.

How the fukk are they more deserving than Notre dame or Iowa at this point?

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

Alabama:

• Lost AT HOME to 3 loss ole piss
• Beat the same Wisconsin team that Iowa did, so that neutralizes any credit you give the other
• Beat joke squads in middle tn, ul monroe, Charleston southern
• Beat weak ass Georgia and Arkansas (AINT shyt)
• Beat weak ass TN, and aTm, wanna laugh...go see who THEY beat between their 3/4 losses a piece, same with above two
• Beat lsu, later exposed as fukk

So their most impressive wins are an overrated and exposed lsu, and a Wisconsin Iowa also beat...and they lost at home to old piss.

How the fukk are they more deserving than Notre dame or Iowa at this point?

Then add to the fact that everyone they've beat doesn't have less than 3 losses so what exactly makes their résumé different than any team in contention?

 

[Black White Sox Hat]

No disrespect to the Alabama fans in here but they keep saying "look at the resume" and not the one loss. My question is what resume? They beat Miss St. Who else did they beat that's good?

They're never as good after we run through em.But at the time we've played them we beat more Top 25 teams than any other team.I think that's what the committee is taking into account.

Wisconsin was #20
Georgia was #7
Texas A&M was #9
LSU was #2
Miss State was #25

 

[smitty22]

Man I think some of you are drunk. They aren't leaving out a B1G title winner unless it's Michigan because they have two losses. They aren't leaving out a 1-loss SEC title winner. they aren't leaving out a 1-loss Notre Dame.

Unless some prime fukkery happens the playoff is going to be

Alabama/Florida
Sparty/Iowa/Ohio St.
Notre Dame
Clemson or Oklahoma/Baylor

Oklahoma will need Clemson to lose to UNC or Florida to lose to FSU and then beat Bama or Michigan to win the B1G

No way the B1G gets left out, they got 4 top 10 teams going into rivarly week.

 

[Illeye buckmatic]

They're never as good after we run through em.But at the time we've played them we beat more Top 25 teams than any other team.I think that's what the committee is taking into account.

Wisconsin was #20
Georgia was #7
Texas A&M was #9
LSU was #2
Miss State was #25

And they was all overrated. Four off those teams got there rankings because they are in the sec That should be taken into consideration.

 

[Illeye buckmatic]

No way the B1G gets left out, they got 4 top 10 teams going into rivarly week.

Has the B1G passed up the SEC

 

[smitty22]

Has the B1G passed up the SEC

More top 25 teams, but they'll point to at week 2 they had 10 top 25 teams in the ap poll

 

[CrimsonTider]

Bama has won 4 games against teams with 3 or fewers losses by an average of 21pts. They have the #1 strength of schedule and they blew out LSU who gave Florida their only loss. Clemson has only played two teams with less than 3 losses and have won those games by an average of 6pts. Than Oklahoma has the #2 strength of schedule and have beaten Baylor who given OKST their only loss.

No disrespect to the Alabama fans in here but they keep saying "look at the resume" and not the one loss. My question is what resume? They beat Miss St. Who else did they beat that's good?

Here we go. THANK YOU

Alabama:

• Lost AT HOME to 3 loss ole piss
• Beat the same Wisconsin team that Iowa did, so that neutralizes any credit you give the other
• Beat joke squads in middle tn, ul monroe, Charleston southern
• Beat weak ass Georgia and Arkansas (AINT shyt)
• Beat weak ass TN, and aTm, wanna laugh...go see who THEY beat between their 3/4 losses a piece, same with above two
• Beat lsu, later exposed as fukk

So their most impressive wins are an overrated and exposed lsu, and a Wisconsin Iowa also beat...and they lost at home to old piss.

How the fukk are they more deserving than Notre dame or Iowa at this point?

Bama has won 4 games against teams with 3 or fewers losses by an average of 21pts. They have the #1 strength of schedule and they blew out LSU who gave Florida their only loss. Clemson has only played two teams with less than 3 losses and have won those games by an average of 6pts. Than Oklahoma has the #2 strength of schedule and have beaten Baylor who given OKST their only loss.

Exactly

Lol @O.iatlhawksfan into detail and then @Ed MOTHEREFFING G coming through with an elementary explanation on why he's wrong

No one is saying ignore loss, we are saying you have to take in the totality of the resume and 1 loss doesnt trump everything else.

I hate the idea of ND had a better loss so they should be higher.

Who have you beaten and how impressive have you looked over the season.

You also can't just look at the rankings of teams you beat because they gets wonky on when you beat team.

LSU, Tamu, Miss state, Arky, Wisky, UGA are all good teams. Being a good team doesnt stop with being ranked #25.