2024-2025 NFL Random Observations Thread

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,477
Reputation
2,528
Daps
63,866
Reppin
The Yay
After thinking about this, it's borderline malpractice that the Dolphins didn't require Tua to put on a Guardian Cap and it'll be even worse if they allow him to come back without one.

He's the first player I can remember in a while who's in legit danger because his brain clearly can't take the hits.
Players make the decisions. How is it malpractice?


Tua isn't a baby. Tua is a grown ass man. He knows the rules and he knows the game. If he wanted to wear a guardian cap he would have.


It's not for the phins to give him ultimatums that don't make sense.
 
Joined
Nov 16, 2012
Messages
7,112
Reputation
571
Daps
19,253
Reppin
NULL
It’s crazy how baker went from out in Cleveland, to thriving in Tampa, i think this the clearest example of a bad organization and coaching staff, i think baker got better too
Baker was bad in CLE though. I think that last season playing with injured shoulder + immaturity was where things went in the wrong direction in CLE
 

Harry B

Superstar
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
30,482
Reputation
-1,388
Daps
61,163
It’s crazy how baker went from out in Cleveland, to thriving in Tampa, i think this the clearest example of a bad organization and coaching staff, i think baker got better too
Might also be gaining many years of experience. Seems like people tend to forget that not everyone peaks off the bat.

Unfortunately for many they don’t get the chance to develop.
 

calh45

Cal
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
11,646
Reputation
2,037
Daps
41,118
Players make the decisions. How is it malpractice?


Tua isn't a baby. Tua is a grown ass man. He knows the rules and he knows the game. If he wanted to wear a guardian cap he would have.


It's not for the phins to give him ultimatums that don't make sense.

The team doctors and coaches can tell players what equipment they need to wear. Some coaches/doctors mandate offensive lineman wear knee braces whether their knees are hurt or not. For example - Bills coach Gailey's mandate: O-linemen must wear knee braces - They do the same thing with QBs wearing a knee brace on their lead leg and flak jackets.

The guardian cap is an equipment choice to prevent injuries just like the knee braces. A coach or front office saying you're not going on the field without a guardian cap isn't some huge violation especially when I don't they can't sign medical waivers in the NFL like they do in college......For context, I had a college teammate who was HIGHLY recommended to take knee surgery, he wanted to play anyway, and was told his leg would need to be amputated if it went wrong, and he had to sign a medical waiver with lawyers present before every game. The NFLPA wouldn't support that type of exemption from the medical so telling him he needs to wear extra equipment is a reasonable request.
 
Top