Who said coddle him?
It's about getting him 100% healthy. Y'all gonna do just like WAS did with Arenas & rush him back too soon and wonder why he's never the same. Being fully healthy & recovered doesn't mean he'll be ready to cut, run & be explosive at a NBA level. If it takes 8-12 months to recover, let him take the yr off breh. Y'all not winning a 'chip next yr, set yourselves up for '13-'14, I'd hate to see this dude be a shell of himself in only a few seasons after this injury
Dramatic entrance, reverse layup mark Arenas' return to Wizards - NBA - ESPN
Arenas tore the lateral meniscus in his left knee in the first quarter of a game against Charlotte last April and had season-ending surgery. He rushed his rehabilitation over the summer and lasted only eight games before requiring two more procedures on Nov. 21, fixing a partial tear of the meniscus and repairing a non-weight bearing bone on the side of his knee.
Gilbert tore his shyt towards the end of April and was playing again when the season started in October. He was most likely was playing before that, 5-6 months after tearing his shyt. He was clearly rushing, people are projecting 8-12 months for Rose, with most saying he'll be good by Feb-March.
No one is saying rush Rose or playing him before he's ready. But if he's ready, he should play. Arenas wasn't ready.