Yo, Davey Richards and Big Mike Elgin got the Meltz 5 star?

FooFighters

Superstar
Joined
Oct 11, 2014
Messages
11,344
Reputation
628
Daps
25,167
Reppin
BKLYN
The only person that can deal with Davey Richards is Eddie Edwards.

And Elgin is a shyt head.
 

TrueEpic08

Dum Shiny
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
10,033
Reputation
931
Daps
17,189
Reppin
SoCal State Beaches
i just watched this match. it has poor selling, poor sequencing, poor entrance gear, a poor ending, etc. what was going on in dave's life that he gave it 5 stars?

I was going to say you were exaggerating, but then I watched it back myself.

Holy shyt, this is so much worse than I remember it being at the time. The layout makes no sense whatsoever, it's peak terrible Davey (even his kicks suck), Elgin is only better by dint of being the passenger rather than the driver, and 85% of the crowd is SO UNBELIEVABLY BORED at what they're watching. It's as if Davey and Elgin don't realize that wrestling without properly built stakes and some kind of investment (emotional, intellectual, etc.) is just really silly adult play fighting. I had to turn it off halfway through the match; I couldn't take it anymore.

What did I EVER see in Davey? :mindblown:

Edit: Watch this madness for yourselves:

 
Last edited:

Jmare007

pico pal q lee
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
45,169
Reputation
6,013
Daps
110,269
Reppin
Chile
we should have a 5 star match watch party

The Coli's reaction to the worst Dynamite Kid vs Tiger Mask getting 5 and Misawa vs Kobayashi getting it too would be priceless. Those are as :mindblown: as any other 5 star match :pachaha:
 

Mikael Blowpiff

#LosIngobernabrehs
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
7,645
Reputation
2,010
Daps
17,183
I was going to say you were exaggerating, but then I watched it back myself.

Holy shyt, this is so much worse than I remember it being at the time. The layout makes no sense whatsoever, it's peak terrible Davey (even his kicks suck), Elgin is only better by dint of being the passenger rather than the driver, and 85% of the crowd is SO UNBELIEVABLY BORED at what they're watching. It's as if Davey and Elgin don't realize that wrestling without properly built stakes and some kind of investment (emotional, intellectual, etc.) is just really silly adult play fighting. I had to turn it off halfway through the match; I couldn't take it anymore.

What did I EVER see in Davey? :mindblown:

Edit: Watch this madness for yourselves:


towards the beginning davey sells like a heel if that makes sense? there's no sense of any kind of face/heel dynamic which is bizarre because even in matches where both are face or both are heel there's still a face and heel and whoever ends up being each thing adjusts accordingly.
 
Top