WR separation & QB accuracy when open chart says a LOT more about QB than many care about

NYC Rebel

...on the otherside of the pond
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
69,914
Reputation
11,069
Daps
236,104
That's exagerrated BS.

Allen would comfortably be top 10 in the 2000s. Yall ignore how up and down QBs like Eli, Vick, and even Favre were in the 2000s. I like Warner but even he had some really bad seasons here and there between Super Bowl runs. Palmer also was living off that 05 season for good bit before he went to Arizona.

The only dudes that would be ahead of Allen would just be Tom and Peyton.
I said it doesn’t take interceptions into account. I also want to get a better understanding of yards traveled in the air with regards to this.

We know Josh Allen is a horrible Redzone quarterback. He’s real bad when he doesn’t have a lot of field to play with.

But when it comes to college, some of these quarterbacks aren’t trained up when leaving school
 

KidJSoul

Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
18,767
Reputation
3,635
Daps
81,629
We know Josh Allen is a horrible Redzone quarterback. He’s real bad when he doesn’t have a lot of field to play with
That doesn't dispute what I said about him being beneath guys like Eli, palmer, romo, Vick, etc.

Eli was a pick machine, Romo was literally Josh Allen with a little less physical talent, Warner also had some crazy high turniver seasons and was literally benched to poor play. It's horrible take
 

NYC Rebel

...on the otherside of the pond
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
69,914
Reputation
11,069
Daps
236,104
That doesn't dispute what I said about him being beneath guys like Eli, palmer, romo, Vick, etc.

Eli was a pick machine, Romo was literally Josh Allen with a little less physical talent, Warner also had some crazy high turniver seasons and was literally benched to poor play. It's horrible take
What’s a horrible take all these quarterback comparisons you’re doing. Tear down what’s being discussed rather than using these arbitrary this quarterback is that quarterback thing era responses.
 

SCJoe

All Star
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
4,124
Reputation
537
Daps
9,901
I'm gonna say what everyone has been saying all season, Bryce Young needs some damn weapons. He such an outlier when dudes are open he isnt even on the first chart.
 

42 Monks

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 20, 2014
Messages
58,118
Reputation
10,051
Daps
215,683
Reppin
Carolina
Is this based on putting the ball right on a receiver or putting it in a spot? Because the eye test tells me this isn't accurate.
bryce simply will not threaten the entirety of the field like the rest of these guys on a regular basis. we run a neutered offense. he's playing a different game because he just doesn't take the same kind of shots every other QB does
I'm gonna say what everyone has been saying all season, Bryce Young needs some damn weapons.
exactly the wrong take

statistically, the panther don't even qualify
 

SCJoe

All Star
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
4,124
Reputation
537
Daps
9,901
bryce simply will not threaten the entirety of the field like the rest of these guys on a regular basis. we run a neutered offense. he's playing a different game because he just doesn't take the same kind of shots every other QB does

exactly the wrong take

statistically, the panther don't even qualify
For the first chart sure but 1.1 percent is insanely good if it means he only misses 1.1% of open receivers.
 
Last edited:

MVike28

right around the ACC
Joined
Jun 9, 2013
Messages
25,259
Reputation
4,693
Daps
104,420
Reppin
T.O.
Reb Kirk definitely short circuits but he will toss that ball deep to his guys

Viking fans know the deal with him.


Carr on the other hand is in a galaxy of his own a downright bytch ass hoe ass coward. He is a fraud who whines and cries after every game. I don’t know how Raider fans did it dealing with him. Saints fans god bless.
 

JLova

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
60,022
Reputation
4,572
Daps
182,242
I don’t know about some of you, but when I go to games, I have a completely different view of what’s going on in the field that the tv view you see at home shows.

So many of your judgments in here can be out right wrong about a quarterback, with them either holding onto the ball too long or taking sacks when so many of these receivers are plain douche and can’t get open.



IMG-6077.jpg


The higher you are on the grid, the more you do after the catch.

Some receivers are plain washed.

Surprised to see DK Metcalf up there in a lack of separation but you see he does a lot once he gets the ball.

There are teams that have shytty receiving cores (Jets, Giants, Broncos, CHIEFS :krs: , Green Bay, Cowboys)

Whats really telling is qb completion percentage when a player is open.

IMG-6078.jpg




Mahomes is the best QB in the league by far. Brock Purdy is overrated as fukk.

Russell and Zach Wilson get a bad rap throwing to bums who can’t get open but hit them at a higher rate when they are open compared to a lot of beloved qbs.

Kirk Cousins and Geno :ehh:

Again…a lot of wack sports talk from most in here who don’t see what’s going on downfield and just swear a qb is ass.

But then again, this is another reason why I feel that being a p*ssy is something that accounts for so much when playing quarterback. When you are skittish bytch, you can’t coach around that. While Derek Carr and Kirk cousins are high up on the list, them being p*ssy is what holds them back.

I honestly rather have a quarterback holds onto the ball too long in the pocket, waiting for his receivers to get open then a skittish bytch who just do garbage check downs, or is outright inaccurate.

When a qb aint a p*ssy, you can coach them up.

Pretty much goes with what I thought. Brock is highly overrated And every objective 9er fan can see that. Not to say he won’t amount to somerhing but the retards comparing him to Montana need to jump off a bridge.

Kirk ain’t Pusey though. Carr yes. Kirk is a gamer.
 

MVike28

right around the ACC
Joined
Jun 9, 2013
Messages
25,259
Reputation
4,693
Daps
104,420
Reppin
T.O.
Pretty much goes with what I thought. Brock is highly overrated And every objective 9er fan can see that. Not to say he won’t amount to somerhing but the retards comparing him to Montana need to jump off a bridge.

Kirk ain’t Pusey though. Carr yes. Kirk is a gamer.
Great minds think alike. He’s a gamer with limitations but he will toss it deep with accuracy and find his guys and has for years whether it was Diggs, JJ or Addison lately
 
Top