Would You Put Brock Lesnar in the Top 5 GOAT

[Kill Dat Noize]

He's not a GOAT, he is THE Goat. If they would pay him full time, he make every single current wrestler job to him. He's not like Big Show wannabe legit, he is fully legit. He is so legit, no one would buy a 1v1 besting him, even Cena, without massive fukkery. He can take 2 tombstones, choke slams, and crotch kicks, and still be at least moving. This is not even counting IRL accomplishments.

brock dominates because he's competing against scrubs.

as much as i enjoy watching him he isn't really a ratings booster or a needle mover. if there were any big time superstars on the roster like in years past, he would probably be jobbing to them.

 

[MrSinnister]

brock dominates because he's competing against scrubs, and as much as i enjoy watching him he isn't really a ratings booster or a needle mover. if there were any big time superstars on the roster like in years past, he would probably be jobbing to them.

Pops are extreme whenever he shows up. Brock and Bryan have been the only wrestlers of last 4 years to get those kind of consistent pops.

 

[Bars4TheCause]

Brock is the GOAT. UFC Champion, NCAA Champion, and WWE Champion. He's not just a legit athlete but a top athlete in three different sports. If he was healthy he would probably be the greatest fighter in the world today, especially with Floyd retired. His 2002-2004 run is the best few year run in history. Brock is great at promos, he just doesn't like doing them. His segments with Kurt Angle are some of the greatest ever. The fact that he doesn't love wrestling just makes him even better. He's not out here complaining about his push, politicking, or causing drama backstage. His current run isn't the greatest, but that's because he's not doing any promos and he keeps facing the same guys over and over.

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

Pops are extreme whenever he shows up. Brock and Bryan have been the only wrestlers of last 4 years to get those kind of consistent pops.

you're gonna go off pops? he's the biggest star on the roster and also the least exposed, of course he's gonna get the biggest pops. but in the grand scheme of things he's never proven to be a big time marquee name like hogan, austin, or rock. if he encountered any one of those guys in their prime (and i emphasize prime)... he would be just another monster heel for them to overcome.

 

[The Prince of All Saiyans]

top ten maybe

these last 'goat' threads y'all been having me HELL NO as immediate thoughts

this one is difficult

 

[Dreamzeedream]

Damn

 

[Cheech&Chong]

Dude has 3 moves and you wanna put him in the goat talk? Not to mention he doesn't even play a character. Ya I get it, he's the big bad bully, come on now. Dude is awful. Can't wait to hear all the stories in 10 years how everyone back stage hated him

 

[PlayerNinety_Nine]

Not wrestlng wise.


But he's damn near untouchable when it comes to working Vince's bank account into a shoot.

 

[Buzzed Lightyear]

Sting
Austin
Bret
Scott Steiner
Kurt Angle
HBK
Undertaker
Benoit
Savage
Eddie
Curt Henning
Vader
Flair
Rick Rude

 

[Metal Face]

He's in my personal Top 10 favs. Lesnar is a once in a lifetime star...not sure about TOP 10 all time though when everything across the board is included. Too many wrestlers.

 

[Heelish]

@mrken12

 

[GodinDaFlesh]

Top 5 monsters yes. Top 5 GOAT no.

 

[Carlton Banks]

Top 10 for sure

 

[Ill-Yaz]

Hell no.

He's nowhere near my Top 20

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

No

Zero mic game