Redd was at least a great shooter and Joe Johnson got way more to his game than Hardenn. And a better hairline.
The regular season numbers are similar is all I mean. People were elevating 'Flopter to God SG status, when really he looks raggedy at times based on the eye test, and similar to other also-rans based on the numbers.
That said, this underperformance is surprising, even given my low opinion of dude's game.