Why are Xbox fans furious over Angry Joe's Quantam Leap review?

MeachTheMonster

YourFriendlyHoodMonster
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
69,033
Reputation
3,719
Daps
108,811
Reppin
Tha Land
TV show is good.

Not the best TV show I've ever seen, but definitely better than I expected.

I'm glad they tried something new. Without the show it woulda been same old shyt as all the other "cinematic shooters"

It can be skipped. Don't understand how it's seen as a negative. Either watch it or don't, the game is still the same :manny:
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
45,426
Reputation
3,761
Daps
68,811
Reppin
Michigan
The Order is a 63
Quantaum Break is a 77
One is pushing 80 and the other is barely a 60 score.
pretty much the only thing I liked about 1886 is the story and that's after the half way point where
Galahad and The Order ran into their issues.
The setting was squandered and people felt like they were lied to. We were supposed to be werewolf hunters and all the supernatural elements were mostly just backstory in cut scenes. you spent 90% of the game fighting humans. The gunplay was acceptable but nothing to write home about.

I enjoyed my time with it overall but it's a pretty mediocre game. It wasn't worth the full price money I paid for it. I would hope QB is better than it.
 

Kamikaze Revy

Bwana ni mwokozi wangu
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
29,751
Reputation
9,383
Daps
76,198
Reppin
Outer Heaven
TV show is good.

Not the best TV show I've ever seen, but definitely better than I expected.

I'm glad they tried something new. Without the show it woulda been same old shyt as all the other "cinematic shooters"

It can be skipped. Don't understand how it's seen as a negative. Either watch it or don't, the game is still the same :manny:
Its a feature that was supposed to be a big deal for the game. If you don't like the episodes, its easily a negative even if you can skip it.
 

Kamikaze Revy

Bwana ni mwokozi wangu
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
29,751
Reputation
9,383
Daps
76,198
Reppin
Outer Heaven
pretty much the only thing I liked about 1886 is the story and that's after the half way point where
Galahad and The Order ran into their issues.
The setting was squandered and people felt like they were lied to. We were supposed to be werewolf hunters and all the supernatural elements were mostly just backstory in cut scenes. you spent 90% of the game fighting humans. The gunplay was acceptable but nothing to write home about.

I enjoyed my time with it overall but it's a pretty mediocre game. It wasn't worth the full price money I paid for it. I would hope QB is better than it.
Quantum Break gave me a similar feel.
 

MeachTheMonster

YourFriendlyHoodMonster
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
69,033
Reputation
3,719
Daps
108,811
Reppin
Tha Land
Its a feature that was supposed to be a big deal for the game. If you don't like the episodes, its easily a negative even if you can skip it.
Again it's only another perspective to the story.

In all other games the "bad guys" are an enigma. You never really know their goals or motivations, other than being evil.

Giving them their own story time ads a lot to the game IMO. Even if production values aren't as good as another show.

For example in uncharted I always wondered why the bad guys existed and how the hell are they already standing inside every tomb waiting for me to show up.

A show/cutscenes depicting what the bad guys were doing would go a long way there. It's good to see the other perspective, makes them human as opposed to nameless faceless cannon fodder.
 

Kamikaze Revy

Bwana ni mwokozi wangu
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
29,751
Reputation
9,383
Daps
76,198
Reppin
Outer Heaven
Again it's only another perspective to the story.

In all other games the "bad guys" are an enigma. You never really know their goals or motivations, other than being evil.

Giving them their own story time ads a lot to the game IMO. Even if production values aren't as good as another show.

For example in uncharted I always wondered why the bad guys existed and how the hell are they already standing inside every tomb waiting for me to show up.

A show/cutscenes depicting what the bad guys were doing would go a long way there. It's good to see the other perspective, makes them human as opposed to nameless faceless cannon fodder.
The idea is cool. The execution was horrible.
The episodes are boring and feel forced.
If you enjoy them that's cool then. I didn't.
 

Animal House

Superstar
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
16,707
Reputation
2,443
Daps
39,164
Reppin
NULL
yeah i seen this the other day, for the most part i agree with joe when it comes to game mechanics and shyt like that. the 20 min vids were a risk and looked good from what i saw especially with the talent they got. i think Joe was a little to hard on the game a 5 means its average but i really cant speak on it since i haven't played it
 

Kamikaze Revy

Bwana ni mwokozi wangu
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
29,751
Reputation
9,383
Daps
76,198
Reppin
Outer Heaven
You say they're "horrible" with no context.

The acting is good. You said yourself the Ida is good.

What makes the episodes so bad?
My Quote was:
"The idea is cool. The execution was horrible.
The episodes are boring and feel forced.
If you enjoy them that's cool then. I didn't."

What do you mean "You say they're "horrible" with no context."?

I've gone into detail in the official thread to which you kept replying that I was just repeating myself.
I've openly praised this game for what it did right and criticized it for what I feel it did wrong.
I think the game overall is decent. Not amazing.
The episodes were a good idea. The episodes themselves were boring though. I'm not going to sit here and post clips of each and every scene I found boring. Once you get past the second level if you still enjoy the episodes let me know. Personally, I thought they were cheesy and did nothing to enhance the game. Some people love Harry Potter. Personally I find it corny and can't really explain why and don't feel the need to. People like what they like.

Again it's only another perspective to the story.

In all other games the "bad guys" are an enigma. You never really know their goals or motivations, other than being evil.

Giving them their own story time ads a lot to the game IMO. Even if production values aren't as good as another show.

For example in uncharted I always wondered why the bad guys existed and how the hell are they already standing inside every tomb waiting for me to show up.

A show/cutscenes depicting what the bad guys were doing would go a long way there. It's good to see the other perspective, makes them human as opposed to nameless faceless cannon fodder.

How many episodes have you seen and what about the show revealed something about the actual game that you wouldn't have found out if you didn't watch the show?
Did you need to be told in Uncharted where every single enemy was and how they got there? Does watching 2 of 80 enemies you kill in the game hop out of a car and stand in a designated position before you actually find them in game really change your experience?

In Quantum Break the entire story revolves around 1 main enemy, his henchman which he doesn't trust, and an army of Monarch soldiers. What exactly is this "Motivation and goals, other than being evil" that you learned about in the episodes that wasn't in the game? Because in QB just like every other game in existence, their is a main enemy and a bunch of "soldiers" on his team you have to get through to get to him. I'm just not seeing where you're coming from with the praise that Quantum Break is doing something other games aren't in respects to the episodes. I've watched all of them expect the last one and none of them have revealed anything important to the actual game.

Sidenote: This post ended up being a lot longer than I wanted it to be. I'm not upset about the game, I'm just trying to answer your question as completely as possible.
 
Last edited:

Kamikaze Revy

Bwana ni mwokozi wangu
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
29,751
Reputation
9,383
Daps
76,198
Reppin
Outer Heaven
Beautiful. People defending "TV" episodes in a video game, DURING a playthrough. :wow:
MGS had 20 minutes cut scenes that I couldn't stand too. Episode or cut scene. Either way the controller is down, and the player is sitting there on Facebook waiting for it to be over so he can get back to actually playing the game.
My thing with Quantum Break is personally the episodes just didn't do it for me. I didn't enjoy any of them. I found the dialogue corny, the scenes boring, and the acting forced.
That aside, when you're rockin and rollin fighting a group of enemies the game is fun. I wish the 3rd person mechanics were better, but its fun.
 

Fatboi1

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
60,410
Reputation
7,938
Daps
110,616
MGS had 20 minutes cut scenes that I couldn't stand too. Episode or cut scene. Either way the controller is down, and the player is sitting there on Facebook waiting for it to be over so he can get back to actually playing the game.
My thing with Quantum Break is personally the episodes just didn't do it for me. I didn't enjoy any of them. I found the dialogue corny, the scenes boring, and the acting forced.
That aside, when you're rockin and rollin fighting a group of enemies the game is fun. I wish the 3rd person mechanics were better, but its fun.
MGSIV had long cutscenes but it was on the other hand, an actual good game. The longest cutscene in MGSIV was an hour and the average was 9 minutes. The biggest offense were the length pretty much but they weren't something tacked on, they were the game. QB seems to give you 20 minute episodes from what I hear that aren't actually necessary to continue.
 

Kamikaze Revy

Bwana ni mwokozi wangu
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
29,751
Reputation
9,383
Daps
76,198
Reppin
Outer Heaven
MGSIV had long cutscenes but it was on the other hand, an actual good game. The longest cutscene in MGSIV was an hour and the average was 9 minutes. The biggest offense were the length pretty much but they weren't something tacked on, they were the game. QB seems to give you 20 minute episodes from what I hear that aren't actually necessary to continue.
MGS cutscenes are definitely integral to the story, but a bunch of them were grueling to watch. If you skipped every episode in QB you would still be very aware of everything that's going on.
 
Top