Where does Pac man rank all time for u

[MJ Truth]

Hard to say overall, because you're talking about mixing a bunch of weight classes.

Keep in mind that in the last 20-25 years we've seen some great careers:

Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Roy Jones Jr.
Manny Pacquiao
Miguel Cotto
Juan Manuel Marquez
Oscar de la Hoya
Bernard Hopkins...just to name a few

To call Manny a top 15 or top 25 fighter all-time...given the long history of boxing...that might be a stretch.
Not saying he isn't. Maybe he is. But the guys who said Top 50 seem more reasonable....at least at 1st glance.

Floyd and Roy are the only two on that list I'd argue ahead of Manny though, even as much as I got love for Hopkins.

I mean, Top 50 goes without saying.

 

[#SOG_soldier]

Hard to say overall, because you're talking about mixing a bunch of weight classes.

Keep in mind that in the last 20-25 years we've seen some great careers:

Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Roy Jones Jr.
Manny Pacquiao
Miguel Cotto
Juan Manuel Marquez
Oscar de la Hoya
Bernard Hopkins...just to name a few

To call Manny a top 15 or top 25 fighter all-time...given the long history of boxing...that might be a stretch.
Not saying he isn't. Maybe he is. But the guys who said Top 50 seem more reasonable....at least at 1st glance.

You right top 20 of the past 50 years. I don't know about nikkas from that far back so I can't call it

 

[Jesus Is Lord]

You think so? IDK about that high I'm comfortable saying top 40-50

y'all need to go that way with the slowed down pac-Floyd fight

His accomplishments combined with his skills, combined with his impact makes me rank him this high. However, upon further review he's in my top 20.

 

[mr. smoke weed]

Floyd and Roy are the only two on that list I'd argue ahead of Manny though, even as much as I got love for Hopkins.

I mean, Top 50 goes without saying.

You'd be surprised some 'historians' (read dudes who care about fighters who we'll never see replays of on TV or youtube), on some weak board that I sometimes post on, had Floyd/Pac at 47 and 48 respectively (in 2013).

 

[southpawstyle]

The way he handled the loss hurt him more than the actual loss. Talking about shoulders, salt water, jesus and shyt.

 

[LauderdaleBoss]

Prolly somewhere between top 30-50 all time.

 

[R=G]

His accomplishments combined with his skills, combined with his impact makes me rank him this high. However, upon further review he's in my top 20.

WOW...lol

 

[R=G]

They clearly had an agenda bro. And Mayweather had the fight rigged and in his favor from the beginning.

LMAO! WTF is going with this board? Sounding crazier by the day..Manny Pac is a TOP 15 fighter OF ALL TIME because of the 8 division? Like that's gonna negate Rocky Marciano being a undefeated Heavyweight Champion or Jack Johnson or Jack Dempsey or Sugar Ray Robinson having that ridiculous streak...the UNSTOPPABLE prime of Roy Jones Jr....Hagler kicking everyone's ass for over 11 years straight...Sugar Ray Leonard being the delight of the 80s...Ali..Foreman.....Holyfield....lol.

 

[Jesus Is Lord]

WOW...lol

Where do you rank him? And who do you rank ahead of him?

 

[Mr. Leonidas]

LMAO! WTF is going with this board? Sounding crazier by the day..Manny Pac is a TOP 15 fighter OF ALL TIME because of the 8 division? Like that's gonna negate Rocky Marciano being a undefeated Heavyweight Champion or Jack Johnson or Jack Dempsey or Sugar Ray Robinson having that ridiculous streak...the UNSTOPPABLE prime of Roy Jones Jr....Hagler kicking everyone's ass for over 11 years straight...Sugar Ray Leonard being the delight of the 80s...Ali..Foreman.....Holyfield....lol.

I put Pacquiao in the bottom 20, but I def feel his resume trumps Marciano. Going undefeated is easy when youre carefully choosing your opponents or your level of competition in your division is trash. What if GGG goes 49-0 at MW beating guys like Monroe and Rosado...is he the GOAT too? And I do rate Pacman over the other heavyweights you listed as well. They only fought at 1 division bro. Champ at 1 division. Pacman was the champ at 8 divisions. You cant keep downplaying the magnitude and greatness of that feat.

 

[The axe murderer]

Top 20

fighter of the decade award
3 time fighter of the year
longest run of all time in top 10 pound for pound list
only boxer to win a title in 8 different weight classes
lineal champion in 5 of them
2nd richest boxer of all time


the fact people try to pretend manny is trash is and we might have been spoiled by witnessing him and floyd at the same time

This is all that needs to be said.

 

[R=G]

I put Pacquiao in the bottom 20, but I def feel his resume trumps Marciano. Going undefeated is easy when youre carefully choosing your opponents or your level of competition in your division is trash. What if GGG goes 49-0 at MW beating guys like Monroe and Rosado...is he the GOAT too? And I do rate Pacman over the other heavyweights you listed as well. They only fought at 1 division bro. Champ at 1 division. Pacman was the champ at 8 divisions. You cant keep downplaying the magnitude and greatness of that feat.

Going undefeated is easy? Rocky is now not credible? Yikes...

 

[R=G]

Who are these great 8 champions Manny beat for titles again since we are running to the competition excuse to bring Rocky down historically?

 

[MJ Truth]

Who are these great 8 champions Manny beat for titles again since we are running to the competition excuse to bring Rocky down historically?

Are you really about to go argue that Marciano fought better competition than Pacquiao?

 

[R=G]

Are you really about to go argue that Marciano fought better competition than Pacquiao?

Cotto, DE LA Hoya, and Barrera are Marciano level and if Rocky is not legit, why make a big deal about Floyd passing him up?