I mentioned SD HCTP as the GOAT already, but SvR 2006 deserves some shine too. That's the very last wrestling game I played, and it was nearly endless as well. GM Mode was fantastic, and the mean reason I'd have it close to HCTP. My knock on it, is though the roster is deep, the non-legends roster was pretty outdated by the time the game came out (which is normally the problem when wrestling games come out, at east that point). Still a great game, but people like Haas, Chavo, Bashams, Jindrak, Rob Conway, Scotty 2 Hotty, Stevie Richards, Orlando Jordan, Snitsky, and Heidenreich were people you didn't even want to choose at that point.
Wow, after listing those guys, yikes, that's a terrible roster lmaooo