2k5.
2005 introduced that hitstick and it terrorized that fukkin game
that was the first game i ever really tried to play online. mfs was rocket catching all day and if you werent doin that there was some shyt where a mf would pick those vikings, put moss on a streak/fade, hike the ball, sprint to moss's side and with that throw power he's somehow throw it 10 feet past moss who would speed up, catch it, and run it in for a TD
combine that with that fast ass michael bennett hb, that offense was treacherous
i didnt play 2k5 online so im kinda skewed in that regard, but if i recall correctly that game did not have spy coverages so vick was eating eating. That game had some real love in it from berman announcing, from the VIP system (it was a mindfukk going against your own VIP and him cookin you the same way you cooked the cpu), a right analog system that helped you chain stutters into jukes, spins and other shyt (i dont think i learned about this til a year later), first person mode, importable rosters, list goes on frfr
i know carmen electra aint play this damn game that VIP was reading coverages a lil too well
all in all, i think 2k5 was the type of football game madden always tries to sell you, talking about espn presentation, a free way of running, not being locked into hella animations, gang tackle animations, etc etc.