What Quarterbacks today would you take over A Prime Mcnabb?

[Street Knowledge]

A Prime Donovan Mcnabb

Ill give mines later

 

[SHAQAVELLI]

Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady
Eli Manning
Peyton Manning
Drew Brees

Romo and Big Ben I got tied with prime McNabb.

Not yet -- but eventually, I'll take RGIII, Luck, Cam Newton, Matt Ryan, too.

I would've taken Vick in his prime about two years back over McNabb, too.

 

[malbaker86]

Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady
Eli Manning
Peyton Manning
Drew Brees

Romo and Big Ben I got tied with prime McNabb.

Not yet -- but eventually, I'll take RGIII, Luck, Cam Newton, Matt Ryan, too.

I would've taken Vick in his prime about two years back over McNabb, too.

This

 

[SEC Hater]

Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady
Eli Manning
Peyton Manning
Drew Brees

Romo and Big Ben I got tied with prime McNabb.

Not yet -- but eventually, I'll take RGIII, Luck, Cam Newton, Matt Ryan, too.

I would've taken Vick in his prime about two years back over McNabb, too.

This. Minus Romo & Vick

 

[MAKAVELI25]

I hope this thread reminds everyone that Donovan was borderline elite in his prime. He might not be a first ballot hall of famer or anything, but the amount of disrespect he gets on this forum is disgusting.

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

Easy

Rodgers
Brees
Manning
Manning
Brady
Rothlisberger
Ryan
Schaub

 

[SEC Hater]

I hope this thread reminds everyone that Donovan was borderline elite in his prime. He might not be a first ballot hall of famer or anything, but the amount of disrespect he gets on this forum is disgusting.

I would never argue that point, he was damn good. But as far as some people saying he should be starting somewhere in the league now?

 

[blackzeus]

Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady
Eli Manning
Peyton Manning
Drew Brees

Romo and Big Ben I got tied with prime McNabb.

Not yet -- but eventually, I'll take RGIII, Luck, Cam Newton, Matt Ryan, too.

I would've taken Vick in his prime about two years back over McNabb, too.

I would only take SB winning QBs over McNabb, only thing lackin' on his resume, not to mention he's 17th all time in passing yards and probably could still play RIGHT NOW. I'll never forget 4th and 26 D-Mac Him and T.O. could have been greatness if they got off their bish azz steez. Manning and Harrison struggled for years, these two nincompoops couldn't handle two seasons together

 

[Bboystyle]

Easy

Rodgers
Brees
Manning
Manning
Brady
Rothlisberger
Ryan
Schaub

Sorry but i wouldnt take rapist,Ryan,or Schaub over a prime Mcnabb. Especially Matt Ryan...Dude is trash...He has one of the most talented teams yet he cant even win a playoff game let alone lead the league in the QB deoartment...Mcnabb did far more with less talent...I mean he made Freddy Mitchell famous for crying out loud.

 

[MAKAVELI25]

Easy

Rodgers
Brees
Manning
Manning
Brady
Rothlisberger
Ryan
Schaub

I'll have to wait and see on these. Schaub to me hasn't yet proven he is better than Donovan and Ryan needs to win a playoff game for me to consider him on that level. Don't forget Donovan won 9 playoff games throughout his career

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

I'll have to wait and see on these. Schaub to me hasn't yet proven he is better than Donovan and Ryan needs to win a playoff game for me to consider him on that level. Don't forget Donovan won 9 playoff games throughout his career

He did, but he was a clown ass bum who choked when it couinted most.

Those 2 still have the opportunity to prove it and win a ring. Also both are much more accurate than Donavon

 

[MAKAVELI25]

He did, but he was a clown ass bum who choked when it couinted most.

Those 2 still have the opportunity to prove it and win a ring. Also both are much more accurate than Donavon

Matt Ryan has two of the best receivers in the league, and a solid running game (prolific in previous years). At one point McNabb's best receivers were (respectively) Todd Pinkston and Fredie Mitchell. Schaub has (arguably) the best receiver in the game, a good/great Tight End, and a top 5 running back. It's not so much that they are more accurate, it's that they are not throwing to bums

 

[Street Knowledge]

Agawd
Tommy
Peyton
Big Ben
Eli
Drew Brees

That's probably it.

 

[intruder]

Easy

Rodgers
Brees
Manning
Manning
Brady
Rothlisberger
Ryan
Schaub

THIS, minus

• Rothlisberger
• Ryan
• Schaub

I know i know.. just never been a Big Ben fan.
McNabb accomplished much more with less talent at WR than Ryan and Schaub has. And I'm a big Schaub fan by the way but still

 

[FTBS]

Easy

Rodgers
Brees
Manning
Manning
Brady
Rothlisberger
Ryan
Schaub

Seriously what have Shuab and Ryan done to warrant being on that list? Give a prime Donovan White and Jones and Turner or Dre and Foster and that nikka woulda had rings, plural.