What are your thoughts about Geno Smith now?

[SoulController]

If im a team in need of a qb in the draft neither him or Barkely is gonna get me excited

yea, as far as just being an impact player in the NFL id take

B. Jones
J. Jones
Mingo
Reid
K. Allen
Fluker (only a RS-So)
Woods
Ogletree

and a host of others, but they will both go top 5 due to position. QB/RB and TE are real dry this year, Lattimore would be on that list too

 

[HHR]

I mean he just put up like 364 yards last game. His defense is awful so he's constantly behind in games.

You think those two statements might be related?

 

[NoCap]

Hes been making mistakes and doesnt look like he keeps it together when things arent going right

 

[SoulController]

Hes been making mistakes and doesnt look like he keeps it together when things arent going right

yea his demeanor worries me, he does get flustered. cant have that in the league, but you get him around enough vets and good coaches and that should fade

i cant really blame him, this was supposed to be a banner year for WVU and their D just ruined it. altho Geno shyt the bed a few weeks ago himself

 

[mastermind]

He still #1 pick at QB but none of these QBs excite me at all. I would be afraid to give them my franchise for 3-4 years. All the top QBs in this draft seem to lack poise and composure under pressure which is the opposite of RG3 and Luck a year ago.

 

[Flight]

You think those two statements might be related?

Obviously that plays an part but I'm not gonna blame him for WVU struggle when they have one of the worst defenses in the NCAA.

 

[NoCap]

I just cant get Pat White out of my head, shyt Steve Slaton either. Wvu stay exporting talent who never performs at the next level, atleast at the skill positions anyway

 

[Ronnie Lott]

Geno smith will still be the 1st qb taken in the draft. He's still a good qb. I believe that if he's drafted into the right system, he could be successful. Dude has a big arm and stands tall in the pocket.

 

[NoCap]

I doubt it, most teams would take a "true" Qb first every time. Theyll probably take Barkley over him, or some other Qb that we dont even really think about but will put up impressive combine numbers

 

[Jax]

Still better than Matt Barkley.

 

[Numpsay]

Someone will lose their job behind him. I told you all at the beginning of the season to temper your expectations for him. People thought he was going to be a lock for the heisman. Dude will flame out in the NFL.

 

[mastermind]

I just cant get Pat White out of my head, shyt Steve Slaton either. Wvu stay exporting talent who never performs at the next level, atleast at the skill positions anyway

That was 3 coaches ago in a different offense and those situations were much different.

Geno is a better pro talent than those 2

 

[NoCap]

Give me Johnny Football!!