I hated Higgy because he turned into complete trash as soon as he got a big contract. Four out of the five seasons from '96-00, he averaged an OPS of around .900 with 27 HRs and 90+ RBIs. Immediately fell off a cliff afterwards.
My number one will always be Juan Gonzalez. He was AVERAGING something like 43 HR/140 RBI with two MVPs in the four seasons prior to getting traded to Detroit. I was hyped as fukk when they got him. I remember talking shyt to a friend who was a Cubs fan and was calling him Don Juan because The Source Sports issue was calling him that and picking the Tigers to win the division.
Dude dogged it all season, milked an injury and was bytching about the fences all season.
In short, fukk Juan Gonazlez.