Time for the annual "Most Overrated Player in Baseball" Thread.

[Bilz]

Joe Mauer

I agree with this one. He's good but that one crazy year that he is judged by really stands out from what the rest of his career has been.

 

[Absolut]

Mike trout. He's been slumping like no other after the all star break. had a good 2 months. came back to reality

came back to reality? dude might get to 10 wins above replacement this season. last position player to do that was bonds in 2004. lol @ that being overrated

 

[Gotright]

baseball is overrated

 

[The Entity]

Joe Mauer has been the best answer so far...

 

[Conz]

dude said Pujols...

 

[Ohms Law]

dude said Pujols...

Have you seen that contract ? Its not meant for borderline players.

 

[HHR]

Evan Longoria

 

[HHR]

Evan Longoria

This is the fantasy player in me voting....for real I'd probably say Starlin Castro

 

[23Barrettcity]

A-Rod. Hanley. Dharvish. Pujols.

do you understand the words Most overrated ??? What rating does arod have this year? Or Hanley ? He hasn't done anything for 2 years .dharvish I guess ,pujols unless you ranking him as the best player still he's not .you confusing overpaid with overrated

 

[HookersandIceCream]

People not knowing what overrated means

Whoever the announcers say is gritty

 

[wtfyomom]

BJ Upton

 

[Conz]

Have you seen that contract ? Its not meant for borderline players.

... dude said borderline player

 

[Conz]

People not knowing what overrated means

Whoever the announcers say is gritty

little "scrappy" white guys. never heard a black guy described as "gritty"

 

[HookersandIceCream]

little "scrappy" white guys. never heard a black guy described as "gritty"

They are however lazy

 

[Boolean]

They are however lazy

its blatant as fukk too

my vote is for Bruce Harper