The "To trade...or not to trade" Thread

[NamelessPimp]

This guy offered me:

Mike Wallace
Jake Locker
Mike Tolbert


for

Andre Brown
Donnie Avery
Pierre Garcon


I am in a 14 team league and there are basically no RBs with any type of worth on waivers. This trade would gut my depth pretty significantly, I'll be starting Demarco Murray and Donald Brown and have Dexter McCluster on the bench

Standard scoring, non-ppr

Keep Garcon and Brown

 

[Clem]

I think when Bradshaw comes back should influence your decision. I think I read he'll be back in week 4. If that's the case do the Giants move to a Houston two-back system or one more like they had when Jacobs was there? I don't think I'd do it.

 

[Bobhoward]

Yeah, I agree that if Brown gets significant reps at RB, I should keep him. I certainly need the depth

 

[NamelessPimp]

I think when Bradshaw comes back should influence your decision. I think I read he'll be back in week 4. If that's the case do the Giants move to a Houston two-back system or one more like they had when Jacobs was there? I don't think I'd do it.

Coughlin already said that Brown will play a significant role. He said all their best years came when they had at least 2 RBs. He said their best year came with 3, so I'd expect them to push Brown.

 

[Clem]

Coughlin already said that Brown will play a significant role. He said all their best years came when they had at least 2 RBs. He said their best year came with 3, so I'd expect them to push Brown.

Ah, I hadn't heard that. Props.

 

[NamelessPimp]

Ah, I hadn't heard that. Props.

No doubt.

Ahmad Bradshaw - New York Giants - 2012 Player Profile - Rotoworld.com

 

[Anbesa]

should i trade andre brown away after his big game
only reason i ask is with Bradshaw coming back and i dont trust teams that use 2 RB systems

 

[Heelmatic]

ppr


brees

lynch
charles
mcgahee
morris

julio
harvin
marshall

graham
bennett

I would take that trade in a heartbeat.

 

[NamelessPimp]

I was offered foster and welker for b marsh, lynch, and alfred morris

neg rep...


just because you made the trade thread and didn't post in it...

 

[#StarkSet]

neg rep...


just because you made the trade thread and didn't post in it...

i didnt start this, it got merged with another

 

[NamelessPimp]

i didnt start this, it got merged with another

I'll hit you with rep when I can get it back. Remind me in a week.

 

[Hard Hitta]

I trade : dez Bryant, Brandon Lloyd

I get: Dwayne bowe, falcons d/st ,

(The first trade I sent him was the same but instead of Lloyd I sent him Sidney rice....I declined the one i posted and countered with: I send Bryant, Sidney rice and Crosby (he has NO kicker who hasn't got him nothing) for Bowe and falcons d)


I been trying to get rid of Bryant but I can't give up Lloyd ... Or should I?







10 team ESPN standard... .5 per Rec

2wr 2rb and a flex


Qb: Matthew Stafford, Alex smith

RB: Ray rice, Reggie bush, Cj spiller, johnathan Stewart

WR: AJ green, dez Bryant, Brandon Lloyd , Kenny britt, Sidney rice

TE: jimmy graham

D/ST: lions

K: s. Crosby, Tynes

 

[Hard Hitta]

I made this thread.... Can I get rep.. Lol but nah what u think pimpin?! ( and anyone else!)

 

[ill]

PPR league.

I'm thinking about trading Peyton Manning, Willis McGahee, and Greg Jennings for Drew Brees and Matt Forte.

Thoughts?

Current roster:

QB: Peyton
WR: Bowe
WR: Steve Smith (Car)
RB: Mathews
RB: Charles
TE: Cook
W/R: Amendola
W/R/T: McGahee

Bench: H. Miller, Sid Rice, K Wright, Turbin, Jennings

 

[Tide Run This]

Who is the best QB I can get straight up for Chris Johnson at this point?