The Ring Top 10 P4P Boxing List

patscorpio

It's a movement
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
120,504
Reputation
11,645
Daps
249,681
Reppin
MA/CT/Nigeria #byrdgang #RingGangRadio
wait I thought eye test was good enough??

I thought belt collecting was good enough despite who had the belts beforehand

you wouldn’t be out here being inconsistent would you?? :ohhh:

show me a post where ive ever mentioned tank being top 10 much less even being p4p if you want to prove me inconsistent friend?:sas1:

plus youre one of THEM that voted for tank :hhh:

a non tank stan OR somebody that has not voted for tank so far would do best to try to pull my card on this:sas2:
 

ChocolateGiddyUp

Superstar
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
17,202
Reputation
2,062
Daps
43,674
Reppin
Chicago
show me a post where ive ever mentioned tank being top 10 much less even being p4p if you want to prove me inconsistent friend?:sas1:

plus youre one of THEM that voted for tank :hhh:

a non tank stan OR somebody that has not voted for tank so far would do best to try to pull my card on this:sas2:


Do belts in multiple weight classes matter or not friend??

do the eye test matter or not friend ??

That’s all I’m asking friend :mjgrin:
 

Dallas' 4 Eva

Superstar
Joined
Jun 29, 2018
Messages
12,137
Reputation
2,586
Daps
42,238
:hhh: so basically you think tank is top 10?

I didn't vote for him, but he has just as much of an argument to be on the list as guys like Josh Taylor and Teofimo Lopez bruh. :yeshrug:

I'm being consistent bruh, Tank passes the eye test and is a multiple weight champ. That alone is an argument for P4P.
 
Last edited:

ChocolateGiddyUp

Superstar
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
17,202
Reputation
2,062
Daps
43,674
Reppin
Chicago
I didn't vote for him, but he has just as much of an argument to be on the list as guys like Josh Taylor and Teofimo Lopez bruh. :yeshrug:

I'm being consistent bruh, Tank passes the eye test and is a multiple weight champ. That alone is an argument for P4P.


Let’s not even mention the LSC W is better than most of these nikkas resume... the best part is it was at 130 where LSC had already fought so they gotta count it ... unless of course they’re inconsistent :mjgrin:
 

Dallas' 4 Eva

Superstar
Joined
Jun 29, 2018
Messages
12,137
Reputation
2,586
Daps
42,238
Let’s not even mention the LSC W is better than most of these nikkas resume... the best part is it was at 130 where LSC had already fought so they gotta count it ... unless of course they’re inconsistent :mjgrin:

Not to mention Lomachenko who at this point last year was the 'P4P #1 fighter in the world and the greatest boxer since Ali' went life and death with Pedraza, yet not only did Tank beat him first he showed a whole level against him and beat the brakes off him.

If Teofimo Lopez and Josh Taylor can be P4P, so can Tank. :yeshrug:

LSC and Pedraza >>> Josh Taylor's resume honestly. Taylor only has 1 good win honestly, and a lot of people don't even think he won that fight.
 

Bigblackted4

Superstar
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
23,903
Reputation
1,525
Daps
40,654
Reppin
Eastcleveland
Not to mention Lomachenko who at this point last year was the 'P4P #1 fighter in the world and the greatest boxer since Ali' went life and death with Pedraza, yet not only did Tank beat him first he showed a whole level against him and beat the brakes off him.

If Teofimo Lopez and Josh Taylor can be P4P, so can Tank. :yeshrug:

LSC and Pedraza >>> Josh Taylor's resume honestly. Taylor only has 1 good win honestly, and a lot of people don't even think he won that fight.
Prograis and at 140 is a better opponent than both he wasn’t brung up in weight like LSC and he wasn’t sucked down like Pedraza. Also beats Baranchyx(took his 0) and Postol(second loss only other loss had been Crawford) and beat the hell out of Ryan Martin and took his 0
 

patscorpio

It's a movement
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
120,504
Reputation
11,645
Daps
249,681
Reppin
MA/CT/Nigeria #byrdgang #RingGangRadio
I didn't vote for him, but he has just as much of an argument to be on the list as guys like Josh Taylor and Teofimo Lopez bruh. :yeshrug:

I'm being consistent bruh, Tank passes the eye test and is a multiple weight champ. That alone is an argument for P4P.
I do not agree with this at all..esp since he isnt the only fighter that has went up in weight...esp there's a mean asterisk on that 130 belt he won. You can thank the "hidden" corruption of the WBA for that:mjgrin:

But it's your opinion and its prolly in the minority too :manny:
 

Dallas' 4 Eva

Superstar
Joined
Jun 29, 2018
Messages
12,137
Reputation
2,586
Daps
42,238
Prograis and at 140 is a better opponent than both he wasn’t brung up in weight like LSC and he wasn’t sucked down like Pedraza. Also beats Baranchyx(took his 0) and Postol(second loss only other loss had been Crawford) and beat the hell out of Ryan Martin and took his 0

Nah bro, all I heard after Prograis lost was how he was always overrated. Just like when Wilder lost to Fury. Now all of a sudden people are giving Taylor and Fury all types of respect for beating them even though they were overrated, so which is it oochie wally or one mic?

That's my problem, I'm consistent with my shyt. If Prograis was overrated and Wilder was a hype job what does that make Taylor and Fury?
 

Bigblackted4

Superstar
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
23,903
Reputation
1,525
Daps
40,654
Reppin
Eastcleveland
Nah bro, all I heard after Prograis lost was how he was always overrated. Just like when Wilder lost to Fury. Now all of a sudden people are giving Taylor and Fury all types of respect for beating them even though they were overrated, so which is it oochie wally or one mic?

That's my problem, I'm consistent with my shyt. If Prograis was overrated and Wilder was a hype job what does that make Taylor and Fury?
Yeah people are crazy calling Prograis overrated hell he barely lost that fight and I’d pick him to beat Ramirez too
 

Dallas' 4 Eva

Superstar
Joined
Jun 29, 2018
Messages
12,137
Reputation
2,586
Daps
42,238
I do not agree with this at all..esp since he isnt the only fighter that has went up in weight...esp there's a mean asterisk on that 130 belt he won. You can thank the "hidden" corruption of the WBA for that:mjgrin:

But it's your opinion and its prolly in the minority too :manny:

That's fine it can be in the minority, but let me state facts for you. P4P is based on Accomplishments, resume, and eye test, correct? Tank is a multiple division champ, that is facts. Tank easily passes the eye test, that is facts. Tank may be lazy and undisciplined but it don't change the fact he is an incredibly talented boxer. You gotta stop letting the fact you don't like a fighter blind you from the fact that by the criteria of how you are supposed to rank P4P fighters Tank has an argument to be there, I feel Crawford is overrated as fukk and I still have him in my P4P list. Like I said I didn't vote for Tank and feel if he should of been on the list he should of been dead last at #10.

His resume is thin, but honestly so is Crawford's recent resume(Gamboa and Postol at the time were good wins but not P4P level wins), Inoue resume is also kinda thin especially since he completely skipped 115 and didn't run any of them tough ass fades he would of had to run and his 3 career best wins all came against guys who were 10+ years older than him, Teofimo Lopez beat Loma and Commey, good wins but still one weight class. Spence is the first 147 fighter to beat Brook, beat Porter and Danny, still only one weight class. Jermell is a 3 belt unified champ, but again one weight class. Do you see where I'm going here? If I spend enough time I can break down any fighters resume and make it look weak or detract from it. I keep the same criteria for everybody.
 

LauderdaleBoss

#TunnelGang #RingGangRadio
Staff member
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
18,412
Reputation
5,183
Daps
57,217
Reppin
Lauderdale
Prograis, Baranchyx, Postol, Martin, Davies , Miguel Vasquez boring ass, undefeated unknown Asian >>>>>>> Pedraza, LSC, Gamboa

Aint no fukking way Tank has a better resume than Josh Taylor. :mjlol:

Dude prolly got one of the best resumes in the sport for less than 20 fights. Took several peoples 0's too.
 

patscorpio

It's a movement
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
120,504
Reputation
11,645
Daps
249,681
Reppin
MA/CT/Nigeria #byrdgang #RingGangRadio
either way in this year. the following fights can happen

the winner of joshua/fury
the winner of chocolatito/estrada
the winner of taylor vs ramirez
the winner of mell charlo/castano/teixeira
the winner between beterbiev vs joe smith/vlasov

can easily push tank out of the p4p 10..these are some mix of lineal and/or undisputed
 

Dallas' 4 Eva

Superstar
Joined
Jun 29, 2018
Messages
12,137
Reputation
2,586
Daps
42,238
either way in this year. the following fights can happen

the winner of joshua/fury
the winner of chocolatito/estrada
the winner of taylor vs ramirez
the winner of mell charlo/castano/teixeira
the winner between beterbiev vs joe smith/vlasov

can easily push tank out of the p4p 10..these are some mix of lineal and/or undisputed

You are 100% right he can easily be pushed off the P4P list, I'm not saying he can't. All I'm saying is by the criteria we are supposed to rank P4P Tank has an argument to be there. He checks off 2 of the 3 boxes you need to be there, and there are a lot of fighters on the list who check off only 2 of the 3 boxes. Hell the only fighter on the list so far who checks off all 3 is Canelo and y'all hate his fukking guts. :mjlol:

Tank needs a unification fight before I will solidly place him P4P, and I fukk with Tank. You act like I don't agree with you, when I kinda do, like I said I didn't vote for Tank, I just refused to change my vote to Josh Taylor to bring it to a tie and force a sudden death cause I'm not high on Taylor like that at all.
 

patscorpio

It's a movement
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
120,504
Reputation
11,645
Daps
249,681
Reppin
MA/CT/Nigeria #byrdgang #RingGangRadio
That's fine it can be in the minority, but let me state facts for you. P4P is based on Accomplishments, resume, and eye test, correct? Tank is a multiple division champ, that is facts. Tank easily passes the eye test, that is facts. Tank may be lazy and undisciplined but it don't change the fact he is an incredibly talented boxer. You gotta stop letting the fact you don't like a fighter blind you from the fact that by the criteria of how you are supposed to rank P4P fighters Tank has an argument to be there, I feel Crawford is overrated as fukk and I still have him in my P4P list. Like I said I didn't vote for Tank and feel if he should of been on the list he should of been dead last at #10.

His resume is thin, but honestly so is Crawford's recent resume(Gamboa and Postol at the time were good wins but not P4P level wins), Inoue resume is also kinda thin especially since he completely skipped 115 and didn't run any of them tough ass fades he would of had to run and his 3 career best wins all came against guys who were 10+ years older than him, Teofimo Lopez beat Loma and Commey, good wins but still one weight class. Spence is the first 147 fighter to beat Brook, beat Porter and Danny, still only one weight class. Jermell is a 3 belt unified champ, but again one weight class. Do you see where I'm going here? If I spend enough time I can break down any fighters resume and make it look weak or detract from it. I keep the same criteria for everybody.

cant use the like argument..i dont like canelo..he is a swagless roid monkey but i havent said shyt about where he is placed..im not a charlo stan but ive said over and over that jermell charlo belongs in the top 10 and can make argument for top 5...i dont believe spence should be in the top 5 or tank being in a top 10 simply they got to do some more..in case of spence the fights that can bump him up that ladder he's not making them..tank needs to pick a division and get rid of some fighters...and im very consistent in what i think of tank's 130 belt that he "won"..now if he wants to strategically clean up a division that's rarely unified..maybe an argument can be made..you gotta stop thinking just because i dont like them doesnt i cant hold them to a criteria lol
 
Top