Debut/Return Of The Year
1. AJ Styles Debuts in WWE (Royal Rumble)
2. Shane McMahon Shockingly Returns to a Epic Pop (RAW February)
3. Shinsuke Nakamura Debuts in NXT (NXT TakeOver)
4. Seth Rollins Returns after Injury (Extreme Rules)
5. Finn Balor Debuts on RAW and Gets Mega Push (July RAW/Summerslam)
6. Bayley Debuts on RAW to a Huge Pop (RAW after Summerslam)
7. Bobby Roode Reinvents Himself as "Glorious" (NXT TakeOver)
8. Randy Orton returns & joins The Wyatt Family
9. Goldberg Shockingly Returns to WWE (Survivor Series)
Fan Interaction Award of the Year
1. Delete! Delete! Delete! - "Broken" Matt Hardy
2. Shinsuke Nakamura Theme Song - NXT Sing-a-long
3. Bobby Roode "Glorious" Song - NXT Sing-a-long
4. Enzo & Big Cass Microphone Intro - RAW chant-a-long
5. 10! 10! 10! 10! - Perfect 10 Tye Dillinger NXT chant-a-long
6. The New Day's Intro & Mic Antics - RAW chant-a-long
7. Chris Jericho "You Just Made The List!" - RAW chant-a-long
8. Ayyyy, We Want Some Baaaayleeey & The Bayley London Chants
Tag Team Of The Year
1. The Wyatt Family feat. Randy Orton
2. The New Day
3. Enzo & Bog Cass
4. Cesaro & Sheamus
5. Heath Slater & Rhyno
6. American Alpha
7. The Revival
8. Tommaso Ciampa & Johnny Gargano
Gimmick Of The Year
1. "Broken" Matt Hardy
2. Chris Jericho & "The List"
3. Heath Slater & "His Kids"
4. James Ellsworth "No Chin Lovable Jobber"
5. Enzo & Big Cass "Realest Guys In The Room"
6. "Queen" Charlotte & "Her Dominance"
7. The Miz's "Intercontinental Title World Tour"
8. Daniel Bryan "Talking Smack/GM"
Fued Of The Year
1. Pi'RAW vs SDSet
2. John Cena vs AJ Styles/The Club
3. Daniel Bryan & Dolph Ziggler vs The Miz
4. AJ Styles vs Dean Ambrose w/James Ellsworth
5. Charlotte vs Sasha Banks
6. Samoa Joe vs Shinsuke Nakamura
7. The Revival vs Tommaso Ciampa & Johnny Gargano
8. "Broken" Matt Hardy vs "Brother Nero"
Worst Booking Decisions of the year
1. Triple H winning WWE Title in Royal Rumble & Having a Boring WM 32 main event with Roman Reigns
2. "Y2AJ" A Dumb Pairing of Chris Jericho & AJ Styles
2. Brock Lesnar vs Dean Ambrose "Street Fight" (Wrestlemania 32)
3. Keeping Seth Rollins Heel After a Very Babyface Type Return (Extreme Rules)
4. Triple H Never Explaining Why He Turned on Seth Rollins for Months now (Clash of the Champions)
5. "Best of 7 Series Cesaro vs Sheamus (some matches weren't even on tv)
6. Sasha & Charlotte Hot Potato'n the RAW's Womens Title
7. Cesaro & Sami Zyan Not Being Drafted to Smackdown Live
8. WWE Doctors Not Allowing Daniel Bryan to have a mega payoff match with the red-hot MIZ
9. Other
"Please Push Me or Release Me"
1. Cesaro
2. Sami Zyan
3. Apollo Crews
4. Tyler Breeze
5. The Vaudevillains
6. Zack Ryder
7. Gallows & Anderson
Shocking Moment Of The Year
1. AJ Styles Makes WWE Debut (Royal Rumble)
2. Shane McMahon Finally Returns to WWE (RAW February)
2. HBK, Foley, & Austin Special Appearance (WrestleMania 32)
3. Shane McMahon Leaps Off the "Hell in a Cell" (WrestleMania 32).
4. WWE Shockingly Brings Back "The Brand Split" (July 2016)
5. All 3 Members Of "The Shield" Hold the WWE Championship in 1 night (Money in the Bank)
6. Finn Balor Debuts & Wins 1st Ever Universal Title against Seth Rollins (Summerslam)
7. Brock Lesnar TKO's Randy Orton in a Bloody Mess (Summerslam)
8. Triple H Turns on Seth Rollins & Helps Kevin Owens Win Universal Title (Clash Of The Champions)
9. The Miz Shoots on Daniel Bryan in Intense "Internet Breaking" Moment (Talking Smack)
10. Goldberg Squashes Brock Lesnar in under 5 mins (Survivor Series)
Match of the Year
1. AJ Styles vs Chris Jericho (Wrestlemania)
2. Shinsuke Nakamura vs Sami Zyan (NXT TakeOver)
3. AJ Styles vs John Cena (Summerslam)
4. Dean Ambrose vs Roman Reigns vs Seth Rollins (Money in the Bank)
5. The Revival vs Tommaso Ciampa & Johnny Gargano (Both NXT Takeovers)
6. The Miz vs Dolph Ziggler (No Mercy/TLC)
7. Sasha vs Becky Lynch vs Charlotte (WrestleMania 32)
8. Other
Cruiserweight Of The Year (WWE)
1. Rich Swann
2. The Brian Kendrick
3. TJ Perkins
4. Cedric Alexander
5. Kalisto
6. Austin Aries
7. Johnny Gargano
NXT Superstar Of The Year
1. Shinsuke Nakamura
2. Samoa Joe
3. Bobby Roode "Glorious"
4. Tye "Perfect 10" Dillinger
5. The Revival
6. Tommaso Ciampa & Johnny Gargano
7. Asuka
Female Superstar Of The Year
1. Charlotte
2. Sasha Banks
3. Bayley
4. Nia Jax
5. Alexa Bliss
6. Becky Lynch
7. Carmella
8. Nikki Bella
9. Asuka
Male Superstar Of The Year
1. Kevin Owens
2. Chris Jericho
3. Roman Reigns
4. Seth Rollins
5. Rusev
6. Brock Lesnar
7. AJ Styles
8. Dean Ambrose
9. The Miz
10. "Broken" Matt Hardy