Supreme

King
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
150,295
Reputation
23,503
Daps
381,656
Reppin
NC
I hope Carr watching Russell Wilson right now so he can see how a QB supposed to play
7cecac71a64434a68e0d5102f1665269.png
 

Troublesome

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
5,034
Reputation
915
Daps
6,913
Reppin
NULL
Gruden has to reduce the route tree for Carr, everyone knows how to play defense on Carr by now. It isn’t rocket science. Carr is the issue.

This is what I'm thinking too. I wasn't a fan of the Gruden rehire, but I don't think he's the problem. I think Gruden gets better results with a better QB.
 

Chris Cool

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 22, 2014
Messages
31,000
Reputation
7,056
Daps
109,302
Reppin
So Cal
This is what I'm thinking too. I wasn't a fan of the Gruden rehire, but I don't think he's the problem. I think Gruden gets better results with a better QB.
If a nikka says they knew what you were doing based on your formation, you got way bigger problems than the qb. His playcalling had been suspect all season.
 

Chris Cool

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 22, 2014
Messages
31,000
Reputation
7,056
Daps
109,302
Reppin
So Cal
If you're working with a QB with a limited skillset, the formations and plays will become repetitive after a while.
He's made the shyt that way. There were a bunch of articles about it early in the season before they started playing weak teams and the narrative c, this is what he got. :manny: He wants a game manager, he got rid of the Cooper, lost AB, Waller ain't a secret no more, ain't nobody else with a damn I ain't :cape: got Carr, get him out of here:camby:. But this offense been trash. Carr at his best was airing it out to Coop and Crabtree, now Gruden got him LeBron James stat padding. It's both of them. Y'all know damn well the shyt would be way different if they had AB though.
 

King Poetic

Business Before Pleasure
Supporter
Joined
Feb 15, 2013
Messages
98,286
Reputation
19,566
Daps
478,100
Reppin
Ocean Floor
Carr is trash

Receiver core trash

Jacobs only bright spot, but he’ll be burned out in a few years with Gruden 1990s offensive scheme

defense is still trash... no pass rush and who’s the linebackers and who’s the best defensive back on the team?? No one

be satisfied with a squad who will stay around or below 500 as long as Gruden in control and Andy Reid is in the same division
 

Troublesome

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
5,034
Reputation
915
Daps
6,913
Reppin
NULL
He's made the shyt that way. There were a bunch of articles about it early in the season before they started playing weak teams and the narrative c, this is what he got. :manny: He wants a game manager, he got rid of the Cooper, lost AB, Waller ain't a secret no more, ain't nobody else with a damn I ain't :cape: got Carr, get him out of here:camby:. But this offense been trash. Carr at his best was airing it out to Coop and Crabtree, now Gruden got him LeBron James stat padding. It's both of them. Y'all know damn well the shyt would be way different if they had AB though.
Gruden after 1st KC game...
Raiders aren’t getting the ball down the field
Before the regular season began, Raider coach Jon Gruden made it clear that he wants to get the ball down the field. On Sunday against the Chiefs, the Raiders did not get the ball down the field.

As noted by Vic Tafur of TheAthletic.com, the Raiders had zero passes on Sunday that traveled more than 25 yards past the line of scrimmage. Making that performance more glaring was that the opponent — the Chiefs — had eight of them.

We called some shots and obviously the ball didn’t go down the field,” Gruden said Monday, via Tafur. Gruden acknowledged that Kansas City’s pass rush put a crimp in those plans. “It’s a little bit more challenging than just calling up shots.”

Right, but not a single pass thrown more than 25 yards down the field when Gruden was dialing up plays that called for them? It sounds like the kind of thing that could make Gruden wonder whether he’s got the right guy in position to turn Gruden’s wish into reality, especially if Carr doesn’t start finding a way to get the ball down the field.

This isn't the offense Gruden wants. He's doing the best he can with a QB that needs everything to happen perfectly to take a shot downfield.
 

Chris Cool

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 22, 2014
Messages
31,000
Reputation
7,056
Daps
109,302
Reppin
So Cal
Gruden after 1st KC game...
Raiders aren’t getting the ball down the field
Before the regular season began, Raider coach Jon Gruden made it clear that he wants to get the ball down the field. On Sunday against the Chiefs, the Raiders did not get the ball down the field.

As noted by Vic Tafur of TheAthletic.com, the Raiders had zero passes on Sunday that traveled more than 25 yards past the line of scrimmage. Making that performance more glaring was that the opponent — the Chiefs — had eight of them.

We called some shots and obviously the ball didn’t go down the field,” Gruden said Monday, via Tafur. Gruden acknowledged that Kansas City’s pass rush put a crimp in those plans. “It’s a little bit more challenging than just calling up shots.”

Right, but not a single pass thrown more than 25 yards down the field when Gruden was dialing up plays that called for them? It sounds like the kind of thing that could make Gruden wonder whether he’s got the right guy in position to turn Gruden’s wish into reality, especially if Carr doesn’t start finding a way to get the ball down the field.

This isn't the offense Gruden wants. He's doing the best he can with a QB that needs everything to happen perfectly to take a shot downfield.

I don’t see Gruden ever being a spread-it-out, all shotgun guy. He’s rooted in tough, hard-nosed football. Offensive balance. Having at least some of the offense with snaps under center. Carr’s best year — and only legitimately exceptional one — was in 2016. They had a suspect defense, but at least it got him the ball. The Raiders had a plus-16 in turnover margin. I suggest if the Raiders did that again, you’d see similar success. Gruden’s goal is to have a methodical, measured offense that takes a shot every quarter or so but controls the action through first downs and physicality. I don’t see that ever changing

Who is there to catch the downfield passes though? Williams has literally dropped every one, Foster not even in the gameplan any more, Renfrow gone, Waller blanketed.

Carr was trash when he did have receivers to go to the past 2 previous seasons though.
 

Troublesome

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
5,034
Reputation
915
Daps
6,913
Reppin
NULL
Who is there to catch the downfield passes though? Williams has literally dropped every one, Foster not even in the gameplan any more, Renfrow gone, Waller blanketed.

Carr was trash when he did have receivers to go to the past 2 previous seasons though.

Oh, I agree that he doesn't have many weapons, and I haven't watched a coaches film since 2017 so I can't definitively tell you if he's missing open receivers downfield or not. I'm saying that I believe the reason our offense is predictable is because of Carr's unwillingness to take shots down the field when things aren't perfect.

As conservative of a play caller Gruden may be, he has still been adamant about the need to get the ball downfield since he's been back. It's hard for me to believe that someone who wants to take more shots is only going to have deep route options in 1 or 2 formations. I think Carr is just unwilling to look for the downfield option unless he's in a situation/formation he's comfortable with and the Cheifs picked up on that.

Like I said, it's been a while since I've watched all-22 film, but I can tell you the last time I watched, Carr was noticeably passing up downfield opportunities for the short, safe option. I doubt that has changed.
 
Top