How Much is Left of Nonito Donaire?
By Cliff Rold
Even after a month where boxing might as well have been on hiatus, enthusiasm for this weekend’s return of modern legend Manny Pacquiao is muted. Maybe it’s the 60-some dollar price tag. Maybe it’s the opponent.
Maybe it’s just that, after fifteen years as a fixture in the US market, some fans have moved on from Pacquiao against a perceptually ordinary opponent like Jessie Vargas. At Pacquiao’s age, 37, one never knows when he’ll run into the sort of younger guy he never would have lost to in his prime that he can’t get by anymore.
That’s not much of a selling point.
That doesn’t mean hardcore fight fans won’t tune in. It’s still Pacquiao against a contemporary top ten welterweight and it will probably be entertaining. However, on a card that will rely on hardcore interest to succeed, the rest of the card might matter more than usual.
There is some interest in the undercard, particularly in the co-feature.
Pacquiao isn’t the only man on the card whose name is now as much a reminder of what was as what is.
Nonito Donaire, the former four-division titlist, is looking to make it five straight since a featherweight knockout loss to Nicholas Walters and move back to the Jr. featherweight division. If it feels hard to believe it’s been more than fifteen years since Manny Pacquiao-Lehlo Ledwaba, it feels just as hard to believe it’s been almost a decade since Donaire knocked out Vic Darchinyan for the first time.
More so than Pacquiao-Vargas, Donaire’s battle this weekend feels like a fight where an aging fighter might cross the bridge to old man. Donaire is only 33 but those years are piling on quickly. For a one-time flyweight titlist, it’s around the age where lighter weight fighters get old quickly if they aren’t there already.
24-year old Jessie Magdaleno (23-0, 17 KO) is live this weekend. He might be more than that. Some of that could depend on the decline of Donaire.
The decline of Donaire is still a debatable point.
It would be easy to point to Donaire’s 2013 loss to Guillermo Rigondeaux as a turning point. Whether that turning point was also evidence of decline is where debate can ensue.
Rigondeuax is one of the craftiest fighters in boxing and proved it that night. He beat Donaire in the one area where Donaire always seemed to lack in comparison to his physical talent: ring IQ. He’d had his share of nights where he’d shown that before, where a lack of Plan B meant less than stellar outings even in lopsided wins.
Rigondeuax wasn’t just better than night. He was smarter. Donaire’s career struggle to make adjustments in the ring was in abundance. Against the Cuban maestro, that was checkmate.
Losing to Rigondeuax can’t be taken as a sign of anything other than losing to a superior fighter.
What has come since leaves more room to wonder. Donaire was behind on the cards when his power bailed him out in the Darchinyan rematch. That was a bad night even in victory. However, he came right back and looked sensational early against a solid veteran Simpiwe Vetyeka before winning on the cards due after an accidental clash of heads.
So then the Walters loss was a sign of decline then, right? Not necessarily. Donaire lost an exciting clash to man whose ability to pack on pounds due to the day before weigh-ins that warp boxing’s weight classes had to give Donaire an idea of what it was like for smaller men to face him at 112 and 115 lbs.
In the four fights since, Donaire has posted three typical for him knockouts. The one time he didn’t is the fight that logs in the column for those who see a fading star. Rugged Cesar Juarez came off the floor and gave Donaire a war; it was arguably the most exciting slugfest of Donaire’s career. Donaire claimed an injury hampered him. So too did a Juarez who fought like his life depended on it.
So now we have Magdaleno and its fascinating stuff. The younger brother of former title challenger Diego Magdaleno, he has some fighting chops and has been brought along as part of the Top Rank machine. The company still does as good a job as anyone of grooming new talent to replace old, matching them smartly and pulling the trigger at the right time.
It doesn’t always work. Nothing ever always works. Magdaleno has never seen anyone in Donaire’s league, even at 33. What we’re seeing though this weekend is the formula at play. If Donaire wins, that will be fine and he can take a positive step back towards higher profile outings. If he does not, Top Rank has a red-hot fresh face.
This might be the fight worth tuning in for.