conflate certainty with probable brehs
football is not just about rules.
"the spirit of the game"
Association football - Wikipedia
It was a loophole in the rules which allowed Suarez to do that, he knew it was better to create a probability of a goal than to allow a certain goal. It was probably the first time such a disgusting act of blatant cheating happened in the history of football. Even the hand of god had some element of deception and deniability behind it. Suarez didn't.
The rule makers wouldn't have envisioned such a thing happening, such a blatant act of cheating. Which is why the punishment for stopping a certainty is only a probability, as you say. But they should have changed the rule immediately, FIFA, so that if a Suarez handball happens again, the opposition are awarded an instant goal instead of only a penalty. The precedent is there in cricket with the LBW law. In cricket you get penalised for illegally stopping the ball from breaking the wicket, and the penalty is basically as though you weren't there and the wickets were broken. In football, you should be penalised for illegally stopping the ball from crossing the goal line, with the penalty as though you weren't even there and the ball crossed the line.
What always surprises and shocks me is how cool football fans are with it, they think Suarez is perfectly fine for doing what he did. They even say that they would do the exact same thing in his shoes. Being Australian I have a very different living experience and perspective on cheating at sport. It's just not the done thing. We banned the captain and vice captain of our cricket team for a year for an act which was NOWHERE near as gross a violation of fair play as Suarez's was. And this, despite the fact that the world governing body (equivalent to FIFA) for the sport only gave those Australians like a one-match ban. The Australian public weren't having that though, and it was the pressure from the public which led to Cricket Australia (equivalent to the Uruguayan FA) banning them for a year
It's terrible, the excuses people make for Suarez. I don't want to win like that. That's not a win. It's like opening up console commands on a video game and turning on god mode and acting like you've won the game. Who wants to win like that?