We only got that ugly ass fight because Winky turned down 4 mil to face Taylor again in a rematch.
He felt he should have won and that it was an easy fight (his face looked otherwise) but his actions proved him wrong by him moving up to face a guy Jermain beat twice.
The only reason I saw that shyt fight twice was because HBO was gonna show Viper vs Baldomier after the re air. I agree with your scores and the fact that fight was a chore to watch.
The sad part in all of this was that moving up to 170 to face Hopkins, changed Winky's career trajectory for the worse at that point. After that loss he had layoffs and became an opponent for younger hungrier cats.