Essential The Official Boxing Random Thoughts Thread...All boxing heads ENTER.

reservoirdogs

Superstar
Joined
Jun 1, 2016
Messages
12,732
Reputation
1,040
Daps
25,583
How the fukk Joshua and jermell not on a pound 4 pound list:dahell: people really overrate these non black fighters.
Who would you take off and why? :yeshrug:
I think the top 7 are fix the rest 3 could be plenty of fighters

w/o order Canelo, Inoue, Bud, Spence, Usyk, Estrada, Lopez being the top 7 is a fix

Taylor, Beterbiev, both Charlos, Tanaka, Pac, Fury, AJ, Loma, GGG... can all make a case for the rest 3 places depending on where you approach it from
 

Bigblackted4

Superstar
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
24,230
Reputation
1,631
Daps
41,268
Reppin
Eastcleveland
Who would you take off and why? :yeshrug:
I think the top 7 are fix the rest 3 could be plenty of fighters

w/o order Canelo, Inoue, Bud, Spence, Usyk, Estrada, Lopez being the top 7 is a fix

Taylor, Beterbiev, both Charlos, Tanaka, Pac, Fury, AJ, Loma, GGG... can all make a case for the rest 3 places depending on where you approach it from
I’d take off Estrada(Most Overrated fighter in the sport) and Uysk(1 win in 2 years)
 

Loose

Retired Legend
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
45,713
Reputation
2,606
Daps
135,655
Who would you take off and why? :yeshrug:
I think the top 7 are fix the rest 3 could be plenty of fighters

w/o order Canelo, Inoue, Bud, Spence, Usyk, Estrada, Lopez being the top 7 is a fix

Taylor, Beterbiev, both Charlos, Tanaka, Pac, Fury, AJ, Loma, GGG... can all make a case for the rest 3 places depending on where you approach it from
Usyk and Estrada, Joshua has better resumes than both and charlos definitely better than Estradas and just about good as Usyks
 

reservoirdogs

Superstar
Joined
Jun 1, 2016
Messages
12,732
Reputation
1,040
Daps
25,583
I’d take off Estrada(Most Overrated fighter in the sport) and Uysk(1 win in 2 years)
Estrada has a pretty good resume... Viloria, Melindo, Cuadras and most importantly Sor who was a P4P top 3 guy at the time Estrada beat him in their rematch :manny:

I see your point about Usyk but he also hasn’t lost since he completed cruiserweight even if those were just 2 fights. He struggled with injuries too so I guess that matters too when they consider it.

I wouldn’t take out Usyk and Estrada, I think they are part of the top 7 and from then everything is up for grabs between those 10 guys I listed. I wouldn’t argue if you put any composition of those 10 to the rest 3 places.
 

Bigblackted4

Superstar
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
24,230
Reputation
1,631
Daps
41,268
Reppin
Eastcleveland
Estrada has a pretty good resume... Viloria, Melindo, Cuadras and most importantly Sor who was a P4P top 3 guy at the time Estrada beat him in their rematch :manny:

I see your point about Usyk but he also hasn’t lost since he completed cruiserweight even if those were just 2 fights. He struggled with injuries too so I guess that matters too when they consider it.

I wouldn’t take out Usyk and Estrada, I think they are part of the top 7 and from then everything is up for grabs between those 10 guys I listed. I wouldn’t argue if you put any composition of those 10 to the rest 3 places.
Estrada would have loss to Sor had Sor not come in with a dumb ass schedule and that faded version of Caudras was putting beats on Estrada

I respect your opinion though
 
Top