The Official "American Idol Season 12" Thread

[Libra Lady]

"make love to the song" Nikki doesn't know what to say half the time... she's grown on me quit a bit tho..i must admit... *hides from misty*

I'm still not feelin' her, but I'm fair so if she says something worthwhile I will give her credit.

 

[Rusty Kuntz]

She can sing, but I'm really not feeling these song choices, man.

 

[Libra Lady]

Will Nicki also critique her hair?

Figured as much...

Performance was good, but really- voice unmatched? Nah.

 

[Libra Lady]

She can sing, but I'm really not feeling these song choices, man.

It is really doing a lot of them in. I mean they are focusing on her original song from last week or whatever. It was a lovely song lyrically but this isn't a songwriting competition- good voice but I wasn't overly impressed.

 

[Libra Lady]

She's getting lost....Why attempt Billie Holiday and not follow through?

 

[Libra Lady]

Sang girl...

 

[Sierra Mist]

 

[Sinnerman]

 

[Rusty Kuntz]

Teena and Amber stood out.

 

[Sinnerman]

Jimmy!

 

[Sinnerman]

my baby went through

 

[Libra Lady]

Kree's not fooling me with that bland look- how Mcphee of her. ;)

 

[Rusty Kuntz]

I think the last 2 spots go to the Filipino girl and Amber. I'm not surprised by the choices so far.

 

[Libra Lady]

I think the last 2 spots go to the Filipino girl and Amber. I'm not surprised by the choices so far.

Same.

 

[Libra Lady]

Shame but she'll be okay. She has star potential but it just goes to show how important song choice is. Still best dressed of the night.


Adriana is going to go through. Aww...