The OFFICIAL 2022 College Football RANDOM THOUGHTS thread

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
41,933
Reputation
-540
Daps
86,651
Heres my question to everyone. Shouls the CFP be based on the 4 "best" teams or the 4 "most desersing" teams?

I think TCU deserves to make it over Bama but clearly Alabama would beat them fairly easily in a game. It's also fairly safe to say that TCU would be a significant underdog vs georgia, michigan and ohio state.

Is it fair to give Georgia a tougher matchup in Ohio State and give Michigan an easy OPP in TCU?

I think everyone just wamts to see SEC VS B10 semi finals anyway.
Honestly seesings does not mattee since your not playing home games anyway.

Geprgia vs Ohio State in the Peach Bowl

Michigan vs Bama in the Fiesta Bowl.

Who would object to that? Those are the 4 best teams in college this year
 

Trust Me

Coli Prophet
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
23,651
Reputation
4,106
Daps
50,481
Reppin
Orlando
Heres my question to everyone. Shouls the CFP be based on the 4 "best" teams or the 4 "most desersing" teams?

I think TCU deserves to make it over Bama but clearly Alabama would beat them fairly easily in a game. It's also fairly safe to say that TCU would be a significant underdog vs georgia, michigan and ohio state.

Is it fair to give Georgia a tougher matchup in Ohio State and give Michigan an easy OPP in TCU?

I think everyone just wamts to see SEC VS B10 semi finals anyway.
Honestly seesings does not mattee since your not playing home games anyway.

Geprgia vs Ohio State in the Peach Bowl

Michigan vs Bama in the Fiesta Bowl.

Who would object to that? Those are the 4 best teams in college this year
This year? I honestly don't know. This Bama team is the least dangerous Bama team in a really really long time.

I think it should be the team that most deserves it, but there's gotta be stipulations. Lets say for example Tulane wins the AAC and goes undefeated. If all they played was AAC teams, and teams from lower divisions.. then naa. If they add a top 25 team or two, and they beat them (like Cincinaatti last year).. AND go undefeated.. how can you leave them out?
 

KingsnBucs1987

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 31, 2012
Messages
20,203
Reputation
2,110
Daps
26,976
Reppin
Indianapolis
Heres my question to everyone. Shouls the CFP be based on the 4 "best" teams or the 4 "most desersing" teams?

I think TCU deserves to make it over Bama but clearly Alabama would beat them fairly easily in a game. It's also fairly safe to say that TCU would be a significant underdog vs georgia, michigan and ohio state.

Is it fair to give Georgia a tougher matchup in Ohio State and give Michigan an easy OPP in TCU?

I think everyone just wamts to see SEC VS B10 semi finals anyway.
Honestly seesings does not mattee since your not playing home games anyway.

Geprgia vs Ohio State in the Peach Bowl

Michigan vs Bama in the Fiesta Bowl.

Who would object to that? Those are the 4 best teams in college this year
I can understand somewhat where you're coming from, but at the same time if that happens, which I wouldn't be surprised you might as well call it the Big 10/SEC challenge at that point.

You'd pretty much be telling every team unless you're a blue blood program, you better go undefeated or you ain't getting a shot and even if you go undefeated, you still may not get a shot (looking at TCU back in 2014 I think when they went undefeated and dropped from 3rd in the rankings to 6th).
 

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
41,933
Reputation
-540
Daps
86,651
This year? I honestly don't know. This Bama team is the least dangerous Bama team in a really really long time.

I think it should be the team that most deserves it, but there's gotta be stipulations. Lets say for example Tulane wins the AAC and goes undefeated. If all they played was AAC teams, and teams from lower divisions.. then naa. If they add a top 25 team or two, and they beat them (like Cincinaatti last year).. AND go undefeated.. how can you leave them out?
If you put Tulane in any P5 conference they would finish dead last in all of them. Having to play that type of comp week in and out would hace an effect on their play all year
 
Top