The Inaugural College Football Playoff Rankings Official Thread

[8====D]

Georgia isn't winning the SEC title game so that's 2 losses right there

Ohio State has 0 chance of making it. They haven't played a ranked team all season long even if they beat sparty in 2 weeks which is a good win, they have no one else. Nebraska will lose to wisky and drop to like 22 or 23 in the polls.

this.

they going to lose to AU and then get smoked by the SEC-W representative

:myribs: at them making the playoffs.

 

[Absolut]

It shouldn't be champs

should absolutely be champs. at least division champs. if you cant even qualify for your conference title game, i dont need to see you playing for a national title

 

[smitty22]

this.

they going to lose to AU and then get smoked by the SEC-W representative

:myribs: at them making the playoffs.

I bet at the beginning of the year u didnt even think of miss st, point being GA can win out,its possible, i think they will and while the sec west beat each other up, i dont think they get a team in

 

[8====D]

I bet at the beginning of the year u didnt even think of miss st, point being GA can win out,its possible, i think they will and while the sec west beat each other up, i dont think they get a team in

actually i did. . .only teams in the west i never respected were arkansas and ole miss

lets say they made me a believer this year

 

[Panther]

should absolutely be champs. at least division champs. if you cant even qualify for your conference title game, i dont need to see you playing for a national title

eh, big 12 and sec are nasty conferences this year tho, their #2-3 teams would be better than some conference champs

 

[smitty22]

eh, big 12 and sec are nasty conferences this year tho, their #2-3 teams would be better than some conference champs

Only knock i have with the big 12 is they play zero defense.

 

[Absolut]

eh, big 12 and sec are nasty conferences this year tho, their #2-3 teams would be better than some conference champs

thats the breaks tho. if you dont at least play in the conference title game, youre out. any system that rewards teams not playing in said conf title game, enabling them to pass up teams that play in conf title game and lose, is horseshyt

 

[Panther]

thats the breaks tho. if you dont at least play in the conference title game, youre out. any system that rewards teams not playing in said conf title game, enabling them to pass up teams that play in conf title game and lose, is horseshyt

fukk all that, give me the 4 BEST TEAMS...

 

[RammerJammer]

thats the breaks tho. if you dont at least play in the conference title game, youre out. any system that rewards teams not playing in said conf title game, enabling them to pass up teams that play in conf title game and lose, is horseshyt

So was the best team in 2011?

 

[Rekkapryde]

A lot of 1 loss teams face each other it'll filter out

Should be champs only but thats neither here nor there

Conference Champs do get a boost according to the committee so that Bama/Okie State shyt won't happen .

FSU
Miss State
Bama
Auburn

will be the rankings IMO. Only way 2 SEC teams get in is if there are a couple of 2 loss conference champs (which isn't impossible).

 

[Rekkapryde]

the problem is there are 5 power conferences, which "champ" do you leave out?

12 teams is the solutions the 12 best teams regardless of winning your conference or not.

Make it 8 with the Power 5 Champs and 3 at large.

 

[Absolut]

So was the best team in 2011?

bama damn sure shouldnt have been in the game, but naturally youre a bama fan, so you advocate teams not even winning their division getting a pass. okie state or stanford id have put in that game before bama

 

[RammerJammer]

bama damn sure shouldnt have been in the game, but naturally youre a bama fan, so you advocate teams not even winning their division getting a pass. okie state or stanford id have put in that game before bama

OSU lost to unranked Iowa State. Stanford, you can make a case for

 

[Absolut]

if its not going to be a requirement to at least play in the conf title game and win your division, abolish divisions and have the top 2 teams just play an extra conference game to determine winner if they are tied at the top. otherwise the team at the top is the conf champ. only teams in the top 2 from each conference are playoff eligible . dont like it? win your fukking games

 

[CrimsonTider]

should absolutely be champs. at least division champs. if you cant even qualify for your conference title game, i dont need to see you playing for a national title

So a 1 loss FSU--- ACC champ.

Should make it over the SEC champ.
Pac 12 Champ
Big 12 champ
and 1 loss SEC at large?

You are are going to have 1 loss teams more qualified for the final four than an undefeated FSU.

What is the difference between FSU and those prime Boise teams?