The forgotten greatness of Donovan Mcnabb
- Thread starter Nintendough
- Start date
Nintendough
#Kliq
Yep.. I'd take both over him..
Nintendough
#Kliq
Rapmastermind
Superstar
NEVER FORGET!!!!!!!!!!
DONOVAN AND DAWKINS MAKE 1 BALLOT HALL OF FAME NOMINEE LIST. ONE STEP CLOSER.
Nintendough
#Kliq
DONOVAN AND DAWKINS MAKE 1 BALLOT HALL OF FAME NOMINEE LIST. ONE STEP CLOSER.
Black excellence and Eagle excellence all at once
Last edited:
Absolut da poet ®
Jubilado
DONOVAN AND DAWKINS MAKE 1 BALLOT HALL OF FAME NOMINEE LIST. ONE STEP CLOSER.
#5 Will always love you
Lol
You have no idea how angry I was when they lost the NFC championship game to the cardinals and I'm not even an Eagles fan
Deitrich Jells
. Fat Andy had him out there throwing 35 times a game with Kevin Curtis as the top WR.
Didn't even have to be that good...just competent receivers and competent coaching. The Eagles really didn't value WR and it seems like they really couldn't identify talent at the position until recently. They drafted Freddy Mitchell over Chad, Steve Smith, and Reggie Wayne.
Todd Pinkston and Freddie Mitchell as your WR core
can only imagine what his career would've been if he could have played with Reggie Wayne
instead they gave my Nikka Reggie Brown
All of the "offensive genius" head coaches (Andy Reid, Chip Kelly, Sean Payton, etc.) operate the same in surrounding their talented QB with less-talented wide receivers that are assigned one job to do in "the system" and run a RB-by-committee. Each are so convinced that ANY player could be plugged into their system (regardless of their talent level), and it would be successful.
And speaking as a Saints fan, I am all too familiar with this offensive operation (Brandon Coleman
).You can blame
and Brady for these teams running these schemes.
Last edited:
desjardins
Veteran
desjardins
Veteran
Can anyone explain why he was so trash once he left the bosom of fat ass Andy Reid ?
I wanna know why he went from "elite" to Having more INTs than TDs and only lasting one year in dc
Then getting benched and
his one year in minny.
I see a lot of ppl in here talking about receivers. Do y'all nikkas watch football or just skim thru it. Certain systems that rely on short passes and TE sets don't need elite receivers. See NE. Andy Reid runs a version of the west coast offense that relied heavily on TEs, passes out the backfield (they ran a TON of screens in philly with westbrook) and short dink and dunk reads underneath. Nevermind the fact the NFC east was absolute trash when they had those receivers which meant the Eagles basically had 4-5 division wins locked up every year. Soon as the nfc east got better when the Giants won that first chip it wasfor the eagles save for the one year they lost to the cardinals in ANOTHER nfc chip game Mcnabb was favored in and took a L
-signed Eagles fan that watched every game of Mcnabb (Eagles) career save for the one in 2008 against the Ravens he was benched in (was in Costa Rica that week and didn't have dvr then )
I wanna know why he went from "elite" to Having more INTs than TDs and only lasting one year in dc
Then getting benched and
his one year in minny. I see a lot of ppl in here talking about receivers. Do y'all nikkas watch football or just skim thru it. Certain systems that rely on short passes and TE sets don't need elite receivers. See NE. Andy Reid runs a version of the west coast offense that relied heavily on TEs, passes out the backfield (they ran a TON of screens in philly with westbrook) and short dink and dunk reads underneath. Nevermind the fact the NFC east was absolute trash when they had those receivers which meant the Eagles basically had 4-5 division wins locked up every year. Soon as the nfc east got better when the Giants won that first chip it was
for the eagles save for the one year they lost to the cardinals in ANOTHER nfc chip game Mcnabb was favored in and took a L-signed Eagles fan that watched every game of Mcnabb (Eagles) career save for the one in 2008 against the Ravens he was benched in (was in Costa Rica that week and didn't have dvr then )
All of the "offensive genius" head coaches (Andy Reid, Chip Kelly, Sean Payton, etc.) operate the same in surrounding their talented QB with less-talented wide receivers that are assigned one job to do in "the system" and run a RB-by-committee. Each are so convinced that ANY player could be plugged into their system (regardless of their talent level), and it would be successful.
And speaking as a Saints fan, I am all too familiar with this offensive operation (Brandon Coleman
You can blame
Nah you can't blame Beli. He switches his gameplan up based on his personnel. I don't think you can compare anyone to Andy in this regard. Not only was he determined to throw the ball all over the field with Donovan and subpar receiver but he would also turn into Mr. Conservative and run a super balanced offense whenever Donovan was hurt.
Last edited:
What I meant by the bolded is that
managed to win those early championships with the likes of David Patten and Givens as Brady's wide receivers. So, these "offensive genius" head coaches figured that they too could do the same with "system wide receivers". So far, it hasn't worked for Andy and Chip (it worked for us in 2009, though 
).You are correct in the statement that
switches up his gameplan based on his personnel, unlike the others, which is why he has managed to sustain success.The comparisons are that each of the "offensive genius" head coaches go about acquiring offensive "talent" in a similar way to
, focusing more so on plug-and-play players to fit the system rather than true, legit talent.
Last edited:
Nintendough
#Kliq
Can anyone explain why he was so trash once he left the bosom of fat ass Andy Reid ?
I wanna know why he went from "elite" to Having more INTs than TDs and only lasting one year in dc
Then getting benched and
I see a lot of ppl in here talking about receivers. Do y'all nikkas watch football or just skim thru it. Certain systems that rely on short passes and TE sets don't need elite receivers. See NE. Andy Reid runs a version of the west coast offense that relied heavily on TEs, passes out the backfield (they ran a TON of screens in philly with westbrook) and short dink and dunk reads underneath. Nevermind the fact the NFC east was absolute trash when they had those receivers which meant the Eagles basically had 4-5 division wins locked up every year. Soon as the nfc east got better when the Giants won that first chip it was
-signed Eagles fan that watched every game of Mcnabb (Eagles) career save for the one in 2008 against the Ravens he was benched in (was in Costa Rica that week and didn't have dvr then )
Stfu and eat a lox and bagel you dirty neckline cac