The Coli Beat Tourney Sincere Noble vs. Mr Hate Coffee

Listen

Tell me moar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
8,665
Reputation
1,477
Daps
22,828
Reppin
A few Floors Down from the Daily Grind
Sorry, but both of these beats are just long melodic sample's with simple beat patterns looped over it. (Obviously some chopping going on, but still.)

:yeshrug:

No hate intended, but I felt like I have heard 5,000 producers make both of these beats before.

I choose not to vote.

:ooh:

Good luck gentlemen!
 

Mr Hate Coffee

Veteran
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
18,715
Reputation
7,073
Daps
73,305
Sorry, but both of these beats are just long melodic sample's with simple beat patterns looped over it. (Obviously some chopping going on, but still.)

:yeshrug:

No hate intended, but I felt like I have heard 5,000 producers make both of these beats before.

I choose not to vote.

:ooh:

Good luck gentlemen!

That's fair. That's why I asked Rod what the criteria was. Its so hard to judge beats. Some of the best beats of all time are simple loops.

Personally, I have over 200+ beats sitting on my hd. Of all types too. Its kinda hard to pick one and put it out there for others to vote on. But I respect and appreciate any feedback.
 

Listen

Tell me moar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
8,665
Reputation
1,477
Daps
22,828
Reppin
A few Floors Down from the Daily Grind
That's fair. That's why I asked Rod what the criteria was. Its so hard to judge beats. Some of the best beats of all time are simple loops.

Personally, I have over 200+ beats sitting on my hd. Of all types too. Its kinda hard to pick one and put it out there for others to vote on. But I respect and appreciate any feedback.

No DOUBT.

Beats are just a tough thing to judge in general. I've got some beats I've made that make me break my neck and my partner will just look at me with the:skip: face....and other times hes throwing himself around in his chair over some trap type beat that has me :merchant:.

It's all very subjective. Neither of these beats felt a) poorly produced, or B) Bad.

They just sounded readily familiar to me is all.
 
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
903
Reputation
80
Daps
1,192
Sorry, but both of these beats are just long melodic sample's with simple beat patterns looped over it. (Obviously some chopping going on, but still.)

:yeshrug:

No hate intended, but I felt like I have heard 5,000 producers make both of these beats before.

I choose not to vote.

:ooh:

Good luck gentlemen!

:manny:

I 'preciate all that. To each his own, I think like duke said there are no criteria for the first two rounds so it was hard to kinda know what to put down. Usually in beat battles, first round, im trying to throw down something big movie type shyt to get em going.
 

bigrodthe1

The Kang
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
12,052
Reputation
2,365
Daps
29,909
Reppin
7mile to SE & Uptown!
:manny:

I 'preciate all that. To each his own, I think like duke said there are no criteria for the first two rounds so it was hard to kinda know what to put down. Usually in beat battles, first round, im trying to throw down something big movie type shyt to get em going.

I agree with everything you stated. first round are simply my beat sounds better than yours :jawalrus:
We will make it get technical as we move forward.
 
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
457
Reputation
170
Daps
1,265
Reppin
NULL
Sorry, but both of these beats are just long melodic sample's with simple beat patterns looped over it. (Obviously some chopping going on, but still.)

:yeshrug:

No hate intended, but I felt like I have heard 5,000 producers make both of these beats before.

I choose not to vote.

:ooh:

Good luck gentlemen!


THis right here is why I suggested a non-sample 100% original composition round...
 
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
457
Reputation
170
Daps
1,265
Reppin
NULL
still back to the question I asked you when you suggested this...how would we know that it's 100% sample free?? It's VERY easy to hide samples now.

It's Alot easier to spot out a sample than you're making it seem tho..if I had a list of the top 100 tracks out right now, I'd be able to tell which ones used a sample and which ones didn't.

We're all producers here..we can tell if somebody uses a sample...

a phenomenal piano melody that just loops the whole time with no extra keys being played? Probably a sample..

If we do have a non-sample round, maybe a requirement would be that the beat submitted must have a significant breakdown (whether its in the intro, transition, or outro) to prove it was an original composition. Simple drums loops (kicks, hi hats and snares) should be able to be used tho since just about every drum sound is a sample anyway.
 
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
457
Reputation
170
Daps
1,265
Reppin
NULL
Also, if a beat has more than one sound playing the same melody, chances are its not a sample, because it takes a lot of effort to be able to re-play a melody that you're sampling... Most nikkas will take a sample, chop it up, add drums and a bass line, and that's where it stops..

Very few producers take the time to learn the actual melody they're sampling so that they can play that melody and layer it with a VST instrument or a Soundfont or something
 

bigrodthe1

The Kang
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
12,052
Reputation
2,365
Daps
29,909
Reppin
7mile to SE & Uptown!
It's Alot easier to spot out a sample than you're making it seem tho..if I had a list of the top 100 tracks out right now, I'd be able to tell which ones used a sample and which ones didn't.

We're all producers here..we can tell if somebody uses a sample...

a phenomenal piano melody that just loops the whole time with no extra keys being played? Probably a sample..

If we do have a non-sample round, maybe a requirement would be that the beat submitted must have a significant breakdown (whether its in the intro, transition, or outro) to prove it was an original composition. Simple drums loops (kicks, hi hats and snares) should be able to be used tho since just about every drum sound is a sample anyway.
That sounds like a round for the later stages...I think by that time all the sample one trick ponies will be weeded out already anyway.
 
Top