The Case Against Mike Tomlin...

murksiderock

Superstar
Joined
Feb 12, 2017
Messages
14,647
Reputation
6,253
Daps
45,417
Reppin
SMF and LAX to VA and NC
Tomlin is probably my second favorite coach ever, and we know he's going to Canton when he retires. But I've given a ton of thought to my Top 25 GOAT NFL coaches list, and he's trending to rank well lower than I expected him to when I first started considering this a week ago...

There are several reasons, but the biggest and most damning reason is his lack of success, with HIS guys. Can never take the Super Bowl away from him, but he won it in Y2. That was Cowher's roster...

Can't take the 2010 runner-up from him, either, but 11 of his 22 starters on that Super Bowl roster were Cowher holdovers...

2013 was the first season more than 50% of his starters were players he picked! And there's a clear line of demarcation in his success from 2007-12 (Cowher's Guys), to 2013-23 (Tomlin's Team)...

For 6 years, from 2007 to 2012, Tomlin went 63-33 (.656), which is a Per16 rate of 10.5 wins/year. In those 6 years, he was a 3x AFC North champ, 4x playoff guy, with a 5-3 playoff record (.625), 2x Super Bowl appearances, and a Lombardi...

We now have 11 years of Tomlin's Team, in which his resume looks like this: 110-67-2 (.615), which is 9.8 wins/Per16. But the real crusher is postseason success, he's a 7x playoff guy, 4x division champ, 3-7 in the playoffs (.300), 0 Lombardis, zero Super Bowl runs, 0-1 AFCCG...

His resume since roster turnover seemingly defines treadmill coach, which, I think he's much more than that. But does he even get 11 years at the helm anywhere else if not in Pittsburgh with a roster that was 50%+ Cowher's the fricking first 6 years of his career?

So he's lower on this list than I would've initially assumed, and I'll have my formal GOAT25 list coming up soon. I've always been a Tomlin guy but I've long said that he benefitted really early from Cowher's players. This is the first time I've actually dug into it, though?

Would you guys call Tomlin a GOAT25 coach?
 

FukkaPaidEmail

Retired Hoodrat whisperer
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
22,777
Reputation
3,993
Daps
87,709
Reppin
The Diaspora
He’s been hampered by bad QB play . Flabby Ben ,Kenny Pickett and Mason Rudolph aren’t going to lead you to anything. He did a hell of a job even doing what he did with them .

As far as that GOAT25 shyt idk because I’m not gonna act like I’m familiar with nikkas from the 70s and 80s like that .

l
 

BonafideDefacto

The Coli's Jetsetter & Globetrotter
Supporter
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
5,843
Reputation
925
Daps
13,360
Reppin
The Bay
Your argument is the same as those stupid yinzer cacs when it comes to HIS players or COWHERS players point/argument. Neither are the damn GM. Donahue drafted and brought in players during most of Cowhers Era as did Colbert during Tomlins. I don't see how people forget GMs exist. If Cowher chose HIS players then Pit wouldve never drafted big ben. Sorry I stopped reading ur post after that cause I'm tired of hearing that baseless argument
 

murksiderock

Superstar
Joined
Feb 12, 2017
Messages
14,647
Reputation
6,253
Daps
45,417
Reppin
SMF and LAX to VA and NC
He’s been hampered by bad QB play . Flabby Ben ,Kenny Pickett and Mason Rudolph aren’t going to lead you to anything. He did a hell of a job even doing what he did with them .

As far as that GOAT25 shyt idk because I’m not gonna act like I’m familiar with nikkas from the 70s and 80s like that .

l
He still had maybe the last 6 or so years of Ben's prime when he was an elite quarterback, and they were still good together thru 2020. The problem is, when Ben got hurt in '19 and missed tge season, he was already in Y16, and they half-assed a succession plan...

He's the coach, he gotta wear some of the blame for picking Pickett...
 

murksiderock

Superstar
Joined
Feb 12, 2017
Messages
14,647
Reputation
6,253
Daps
45,417
Reppin
SMF and LAX to VA and NC
Your argument is the same as those stupid yinzer cacs when it comes to HIS players or COWHERS players point/argument. Neither are the damn GM. Donahue drafted and brought in players during most of Cowhers Era as did Colbert during Tomlins. I don't see how people forget GMs exist. If Cowher chose HIS players then Pit wouldve never drafted big ben. Sorry I stopped reading ur post after that cause I'm tired of hearing that baseless argument
We not gonna play this game like the coach has no influence over his roster...
 

Based Lord Zedd

Colts or Die
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
11,006
Reputation
1,417
Daps
30,398
Reppin
Houston TX
Tomlin's weakness IMO is that he isn't an offensive coach and doesn't seem too involved in personnel decisions. In a QB/offense-driven league that's a problem. Also where is his coaching tree?

I think he's top 25 though, considering he is #12 all time in wins, with 2 SB appearances and a ring.
 
Last edited:

Redguard

Hoonding
Joined
Oct 18, 2013
Messages
10,693
Reputation
1,443
Daps
30,394
Reppin
Hammerfell
We not gonna play this game like the coach has no influence over his roster...

licensed-image




/thread
 
Top