I have a PS5 & gaming PC so I have no dog in this race but...
Starfield will take priority imho
I already kinda know what to expect from Spider-Man. even if Starfield just ends up being Skyrim in space....that's still an interesting concept to me and a game I want to play
I'll save Spider-Man 2 for the holidays
So here's the answer regardless of what anybody here says.
Spiderman like all things Marvel are not main courses. They are desserts. They are tasty, fun, but lack any real SUBSTANCE
Starfield is like the slow crafting of a masterpiece. Think Martin Scorsese type big deal
Starfield has the EXPECTATIONS of being an all time classic moving genres forward in ways never done.
Spiderman isn't trying to be and isn't expected to do any of that. But its a sony exclusive so the sony fanboys will act like its just as good as anything before it. Sony gamers don't even like Uncharted but will name drop it in a heartbeat. So a thread like this will mostly solicit sony fanboy responses.
Spiderman should be the winner in this websites poll but Starfield is by far the bigger game, the more important game. And if it delivers? Will be the biggest game in history when its all said and done.... until the next big game comes along.
I too don't care for space games too much but I'll give it a shot. I mean, I grew up on Alpha Mission and R-Type/etc. So space is like, coool