SPIN: Your Top 10 Point Guards IN THEIR PRIMES

[Wacky D]

list your top 10 point guards judging by just their primes.

feel free to post your overall all-time list.

 

[28 Gramz]

Magic
Big O
Steph
Zeek
Rose
CP3
Russ
Penny
Kidd
Glove

 

[Originalgangsta317]

Magic
Oscar
Zeke
Russ
Steph
Rose
Cp3
Penny
GP
Stockton

 

[Tony D'Amato]

@ no point was Derrick Rose better than prime PHx Nash

 

[Wacky D]

10. gilbert arenas(wildcard pick)
9. gary payton
8. jason kidd
7. nate archibald
6. steph curry
5. derrick rose
4. penny hardaway
3. isaiah thomas
2. magic johnson
1. oscar robertson


as for my all-time list:
10. chris paul - (wildcard pick - changes everytime i upp this thread. give me chris paul today.)
9. walt frazier
8. steph curry
7. gary payton
6. nate archibald
5. john stockton
4. jason kidd
3. isaiah thomas
2. oscar robertson
1. magic johnson


for the record, when it comes to my overall goat player list(not just by position), oscar robertson is easily ahead of magic johnson.

 

[Wacky D]

@ no point was Derrick Rose better than prime PHx Nash

prime nash was a glorified system player.

still gets a nod tho.

 

[28 Gramz]

Forgot about Penny...Nash can kick rocks.

 

[Originalgangsta317]

@ no point was Derrick Rose better than prime PHx Nash

Don't start wit yo bullshyt

 

[28 Gramz]

@ no point was Derrick Rose better than prime PHx Nash

25, 7.5 & 4 and MVP at 21 years old D Rose>>>>>>Nash at any fukking point.

 

[Sly Cookin]

Baron Davis

 

[onelastdeath]

@ no point was Derrick Rose better than prime PHx Nash

GTFO

 

[sportscribe]

Magic
Curry
Paul
Robertson
Payton
Thomas
Kidd
Nash
Stockton
Parker


So no one feels Tony Parker in his prime was a top 10 player?

Prime TP was almost unstoppable in the paint. Breh had multiple seasons shooting over 50%. Majority of the guys on the these top 10 lists haven't even had a single season shooting over 50%.

 

[Anerdyblackguy]

Top 10 point guards

1) Magic Johnson ( To versatile to pass on)
2) Jason Kidd ( What he did with that NETS team)
3) Russell Westbrook ( His prime is better than D-rose)
4) Isiah Thomas ( Great leader)
5)Chris Paul ( Makes every team better)
6)Gary Payton ( I love defense more than offense)
7) Steve Nash( Better offense facilitator than Curry)
8) Steph Curry( That three point shooting is insane)
9) Oscar Robertson ( Would have him higher, just never seen him play)
10) Derrick Rose ( His speed in his prime was insane)

 

[Tony D'Amato]

25, 7.5 & 4 and MVP at 21 years old D Rose>>>>>>Nash at any fukking point.

Where is the FGA and FG%

prime nash was a glorified system player.

still gets a nod tho.

There isn't a system invented that Mute could be that efficient in

 

[Consumed]

Curry
Magic
Westbrook
Oscar
Paul
Penny
Nash
Thomas
Stockton
Payton

Obviously not a fan of Kidd and the order of this list can vary by the argument. More of a peak ranking than prime which factors longevity

Magic
Curry
Paul
Robertson
Payton
Thomas
Kidd
Nash
Stockton
Parker


So no one feels Tony Parker in his prime was a top 10 player?

Prime TP was almost unstoppable in the paint. Breh had multiple seasons shooting over 50%. Majority of the guys on the these top 10 lists haven't even had a single season shooting over 50%.

Nah. TP was nice but he's not top ten worthy in terms of prime/peak play. Gilbert Arenas was better.