It's crazy how determining male attractiveness differs between men and women.
If you asked me (as a guy that likes women) who was more attractive between D'Angelo and Ginuwine, I would've said something along the lines of "Ginuwine has atypical black hair and is brown-skinned and he looks more like what a woman would probably want in a guy, so he probably gets more women."
I'm 25 and still don't know what women find attractive
. I get told all the time that I'm ugly as hell, and I fit the ginuwine mold mostly (Brown / light-skinned, curly hair, great bone structure). I've actually been told that I look a little flamboyant.