So now that the show is over, which New Orleans WrestleMania was better? WM 30 or WM 34?

[mannyrs13]

Can't compare in my opinion. 30 had the moments. From the Daniel Bryan matches to Brock beating the undertaker. Wasn't a big card and most of the wrestlers today weren't around, but it felt like a big event. 34 felt like a regular ppv. Not one big moment I can recall except maybe Nia winning the title and Naomi winning but not something as memorable as Daniel Bryan ending the show. They got lazy with the booking chees past few months so nothing felt special.

 

[NoMorePie]

WrestleMania 30. By far. 34 started off hot but jeez the main event trash but Brock winning was a shock.

 

[Doctor Wily]

 

[qnsfinest]

WrestleMania 30 had the greater "mania moment" but Mania 34 was overall better from a wrestling standpoint

Dbry vs HHH- Great match
Battle Royal- Average
Shield vs kane and NAO- Horse shyt
Cena vs Wyatt- Average to good match
lesnar vs taker- average match but great moment
Divas match- Meh
Triple Threat- Good Match, again Dbry winning was an historic moment and will be one of the greatest mania moments ever.

Mania 34-
IC Title triple threat- 4+ star match, Best match of the night and better than any match from mania 30
Asuka vs charlotte- another great 4 star match
US title- Average
Mix tag match- Entertaining as hell, most entertaining match of the night, with all the bells and whistles
smackdown tag match- trash
taker vs cena- trash
shane/Dbry vs owens/Zayn- Good match
Raw womens title- Average
AJ vs Nak- great match, easily a 4star match
lesnar vs roman- average match

The only reason Mania 30 was better because of Dbry's coronation and the shows length. But 34 had much better wrestling.

 

[Rell84shots]

WM XXX, The opening & main event were crazy and the atmosphere after Taker lost was surreal.

 

[Ill Lou Malnati]

They are equal to me. 30 had two good matches and two good moments. 34 had three good matches and one good moment. Neither is a standout in the grand scheme.

 

[Playaz Eyez]

They are equal to me. 30 had two good matches and two good moments. 34 had three good matches and one good moment. Neither is a standout in the grand scheme.

Clearly 30 was a standout in the grand scheme, but as far as 34, would Ronda’s showcase be considered the one good moment?

 

[Ill Lou Malnati]

Clearly 30 was a standout in the grand scheme, but as far as 34, would Ronda’s showcase be considered the one good moment?

Ronda was a good match, but you could count that as a good moment as well because of the spectacle of it. What I had in mind as a good moment was DB returning because the match itself was not good thanks to the first half, which was unnecessary booking and completely killed the crowd.

 

[DANJ!]

Can't compare in my opinion. 30 had the moments. From the Daniel Bryan matches to Brock beating the undertaker. Wasn't a big card and most of the wrestlers today weren't around, but it felt like a big event. 34 felt like a regular ppv. Not one big moment I can recall except maybe Nia winning the title and Naomi winning but not something as memorable as Daniel Bryan ending the show. They got lazy with the booking chees past few months so nothing felt special.

So Taker's return, DB's first match in 3 years, Naka's heel turn, Rousey... not as notable as the two things you mentioned?

 

[CM_Burns]

Streak ending
Rock/Austin/Hogan segment
D Bry winning

All were much more memorable than anything that happened tonight. And the pacing was much better. It's not even close imo

 

[mannyrs13]

So Taker's return, DB's first match in 3 years, Naka's heel turn, Rousey... not as notable as the two things you mentioned?

The taker thing is getting tiring by now. Could've easily given the spot to another superstar. Who else is left for him to even wrestle? Ok I will say the Daniel Bryan thing, yes. Not sure how I feel about the naka heel turn. I guess they needed a heel for AJ. Who else on SD is even worthy enough of taking the title from him? Rousey did good for her first match. Could've been better than Hunter and Steph but still decent. Just didn't feel like one of those mark out moments like when she appeared at the rumble. It was obvious she was gonna win anyways. But still a good match regardless.

But in my opinion, takeover was way better than Mania. Great matches, story telling, and psychology. I wouldn't say this was the worst mania, but I wouldn't put it in the top ten.

 

[Playaz Eyez]

Ronda was a good match, but you could count that as a good moment as well because of the spectacle of it. What I had in mind as a good moment was DB returning because the match itself was not good thanks to the first half, which was unnecessary booking and completely killed the crowd.

Ahhhh ok gotcha, makes sense