I used to think like this, and copped my first iphone a few months ago
now, granted. i'm not a power user of phones. i use it to do social media, browse the web, talk to friends, and arrange social outings w/ women (emoticons help here).
1st off, it's just much much smoother/responsive
2nd of all, the apps shyt all over android apps
3rd of all, Siri as a personal assistant>google now, and i get google now anyway
4th of all, imessage...not to be corny but i keep in touch much better w/ my friends w/ iphones
5th of all, sound quality from an iphone is much better imo
6th of all, yes, the shyt just feels premium
i tried to use my galaxy the other day just on wifi and the shyt almost felt unusable w/ how laggy it was. just seems like samsung comes w/ a bunch of gimmicks yet still cant touch the apple offering. vertical integration>*
Htc one (either version) begs to differ with all points listed except #2... And its been quite a while since ive seen an iphone app that doesnt work and android.