I'm not saying I don't believe you, but we might just have different number systems
Anything above a 7 is exceptionally attractive, 6 is average to moderately attractive. When you hit the 8 or 9s those are Hollywood type chicks, as in chicks that could literally make a career off of their looks. 9s/10s are super model types. There is no way a chick who is moderately attractive (a 5) can use make up and magically become an 8/9.
My girl is a 9 to me with makeup on...heck somedays she is a 10.
I'm sure someone somewhere will probably think she is a 10 with no makeup on
"Beauty is in the eye of the beholder"