She-Hulk show on Disney + Announced (Tatiana Maslany Cast)
- Thread starter Bigbigguy
- Start date
They need to use comic fans in the writers room.
At the very least use people who respect the artform enough to read the actual comics and try to honor them.
Will they ever make romantic comedies that shyt on their core audience - women - and appeal to men? You already know that would backfire. Doesn't even make sense when put that way.
How you gonna make a comic book property that rejects the people who love comics?
It's totally obvious. It's amazing that anyone older than 13 could think something like that could ever work.
I liked it all right but they left out the most important part. A good villian and quality action.
They even shytted on the Daredevil hallway fight as if it's some kind of joke. To real comic fans the Netflix DD action was groundbreaking and superior to anything in these D+ shows.
At the very least use people who respect the artform enough to read the actual comics and try to honor them.
Will they ever make romantic comedies that shyt on their core audience - women - and appeal to men? You already know that would backfire. Doesn't even make sense when put that way.
How you gonna make a comic book property that rejects the people who love comics?
It's totally obvious. It's amazing that anyone older than 13 could think something like that could ever work.
I liked it all right but they left out the most important part. A good villian and quality action.
They even shytted on the Daredevil hallway fight as if it's some kind of joke. To real comic fans the Netflix DD action was groundbreaking and superior to anything in these D+ shows.
Diondon
Thanks to the lawyers uh, I marbled the foyer
I liked it except for the finale
Json
Superstar
Epic fail on that person's part then.
We had Skaar, Abomination, She Hulk, Titania, and Smart Hulk.
And Daredevil.
You telling me we couldn't get a massively ill brawl out of this?
Think about Civil War and other MCU movies. Even the Netflix shows. Comics are largely like wrestling. About fighting amongst super humans.
Json
Superstar
I mean comedy superhero comic books usually subvert a lot of those tropes as apart of their charm.
And they aren’t usually among the higher selling books. They just tend to garner passionate fans.
Deadpool was never a top selling comic even as an X-man.
So we all agree this show is kinda shytty right... 
All they do is break the 4th wall and try to make jokes that they think will make us laugh... It was coo the first few eps but eh....
All they do is break the 4th wall and try to make jokes that they think will make us laugh... It was coo the first few eps but eh....
AnonymityX1000
Veteran
Says having a comic writer not on staff is the problem.
Finds out there is one and quickly changes to "It doesn't matter." lol
Just say you didn't like it as much as you would have liked. No need to try to "solve the problem".
She-Hulk is a character that pokes fun at a lot of that stuff though...same stuff that Marvel has been previously crtiticized for, constantly trying to maintain world ending stakes, the big final brawls and cookie cutter story arcs ect.
The show is probably one of the closer page to screen adapations in that way, if you look at her comics, she stays talking shyt to readers, pointing up the wacky, low budget villans, critiziing and even beating up writers and creative for their choices. If anything, it would take someone unfamiliar with her comics to do the the show like a standard MCU project.
Last edited:
I don't like the idea that only people who hated it were incels.
I enjoyed the show, especially in the binge format the second time around but there are plenty of legit reasons to not like the show. I think a part of it is, some people were probably expecting "Hulk-girl" as in a character who fits into the standard MCU tropes who just happens to be female, not actually a show made by women with appealing to women in mind. Nor are some of them familiar with the fact that the point of the character is to lampoon Marvel and it's fans a lot of times, fans that routinely take themselves and the MCU especially way too fukking serious.
humminbird
Veteran
yeah if you binge this it's pretty good
I think this should've been 6 instead of 9 eps too
6 eps with a little longer runtimes would have been the sweet spot. I don't want everything to be a "Special" now that it looks like they might have a new workin formula, but imagine watching WWBN chopped up into 20 minute parts lol, fukk that.
That should be the title of S2 if she gets one, and she should IMO.
humminbird
Veteran
yeah I loved the she-hulk character and I'm down for another season with more focus I think it'll be a banger6 eps with a little longer runtimes would have been the sweet spot. I don't want everything to be a "Special" now that it looks like they might have a new workin formula, but imagine watching WWBN chopped up into 20 minute parts lol, fukk that.
That should be the title of S2 if she gets one, and she should IMO.
you really needed another massively ill brawl?
