Seth Rogen vs. Jonah Hill

[mitter]

The battle of funny, overweight, ugly-ish Jewish guys

Who made the best movies?

Who had the best performances?

Which team are you on?

 

[jdubnyce]

Jonah for Superbad and Wolf of Wall Street >>>

 

[mitter]

Jonah for Superbad and Wolf of Wall Street >>>

Maybe.


But let's not sleep on Rogen's run from 2007-2009

Knocked Up
Superbad (yeah, a much smaller role than Jonah Hill, but still)
Pineapple Express
Zack and Miri Make a Porno
Observe and Report
Funny People


I just wish he had kept making stuff like that

 

[jdubnyce]

Maybe.


But let's not sleep on Rogen's run from 2007-2009

Knocked Up
Superbad (yeah, a much smaller role than Jonah Hill, but still)
Pineapple Express
Zack and Miri Make a Porno
Observe and Report
Funny People


I just wish he had kept making stuff like that

Seth is essentially playing Seth in all but Funny People.

Jonah >>>

 

[mitter]

Seth is essentially playing Seth in all but Funny People.

Jonah >>>

Works for me



And let's not forget, Jonah is playing Seth in Superbad

 

[mtg]

I like the little bit of diversity Jonah has with his roles and I would say he’s just a better actor too. However Seth if he keeps on this path may become one of the more important Hollywood producers I could see him picking some obscure ip and really turning it to a major money maker even more so than the boys.

 

[Soymuscle Mike]

Seth is way funnier in his own flicks when you can tell they're freestyling. Jonah is, obviously, way better with scripted stuff since he's a legit actor and Seth is a writer who happens to look funny so it sometimes works on screen.

They pretty much even out imo. Seth has made/been a big part of funnier movies but Jonah has the better performances.

 

[JoseLuisGotcha]

Seth always plays the goofy stoner

jonah got raaaaange he can do funny shyt like Seth but has some dope serious roles and can sprinkle comedy in them too

 

[Mike Nasty]

Jonah, easily
Super Bad
War Dogs
Had the funniest lines in Knocked up.
was funny in his 30s in 40 Year old Virgin.

 

[Ukbrotha]

Jonah for me.

 

[Verbal Kint]

Rogan. 40 yr old virgin, pineapple express and neighbors. Nuff said. Thiugh Jonah isln Superbad is the best of all those performances

 

[AnonymityX1000]

Jonah, in that movie Funny People Seth is the star while Jonah is just supporting but he is way funnier in that movie to me.
That end of the world movie to Jonah outdoes him there as well but it's closer. They both really aren't that funny in that. Danny Mcbride saved that movie from sucking actually.

 

[SuburbanPimp]

Jonah is a better actor ... Seth is funnier, imo

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Seth don't have performances like Jonah in Moneyball and Wolf of Wall Street. Jonah a damn good actor. Seth can be funny tho.

 

[StraxStrax]

Does Seth get points for making Jonah a star?