Broke Wave
The GOAT
Is there a reason it can't be a bit of both? The Saudi Royal family doesn't give a fukk about Islam, we all know this. Yet, they still go out of their way to appease a very vocal and significant religious demographic. This isn't my opinion by the way, this is coming from people FROM Saudi Arabia. People I know currently in the US studying.
Yeah man I understand the complexity of the situation and how Islamic extremism excacerbates the situation. As a qualifier I have been to Saudi Arabia and I have family who have been there for 25+ years who still haven't been granted citizenship which is xenophobic racism, and that is prohibited in Islam, but they still persue this policy. The point I'm trying to make is essentially when a new psychotic policy comes from Saudi, maybe female branding like cattle, the Saudi's will find a hadith to support this in some way and the trick they will play is that people will be like "yeah I guess this is Islam", when it is just their perverse interpretation. Maybe if you converted everyone to another faith or atheism they're wouldn't be this specific problem but such a thing isn't possible, and wouldn't address the root cause. Military junta's are more common than theocracies and are almost always secular rationalist.