She wasn't even the best looking woman on Buffy.
Charisma Carpenter >>>
Eliza Dushku >>>
She's up there with Neve Campbell for 90s girls who I never saw the hype for.
Charisma yes. Good God that's fine white girl!
but Eliza better than Sarah? No sir.

and don't get me wrong, Eliza is bad, I just think Sarah looks better.
As for Neve Campbell it wasn't until last year when I made a thread for her and looking back at her pictures that I realized she was attractive.
I didn't really feel her back in the late 90's but now looking back she ain't bad looking at all.
The more that I think about it, Neve Campbell is actually the type of woman, look wise, I could see myself marrying. Average attractive woman.