Ryan clark says russell wilson is not a all time great qb

NoHalfWay

Superstar
Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Messages
16,061
Reputation
2,745
Daps
53,173
Reppin
813
It depend on what you define an all time great QB as.

If an all time great QB is one of the 25 best QBs to play, Russ definitely belongs in the convo

If you narrowing all time great QBs to only 10 or 15 guys, then no you’re probably not gonna consider him all time great.
 

Llcoolbay

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Jun 10, 2014
Messages
16,072
Reputation
1,541
Daps
41,425
Reppin
St Louis Rams!!!!!
By that definition there aren't many all time greats then

But i will say Russ seems to have escaped criticism for his playoff performances since the superbowl when he has lost I think 3 of his last 4 playoff game being on home field?


Edit: someone corrected me it is actually on the road not at home
 
Last edited:

MJ Truth

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 1, 2015
Messages
38,355
Reputation
3,600
Daps
152,818
It depend on what you define an all time great QB as.

If an all time great QB is one of the 25 best QBs to play, Russ definitely belongs in the convo

If you narrowing all time great QBs to only 10 or 15 guys, then no you’re probably not gonna consider him all time great.
Russ is in the top 15 conversation at the very least. He’s just not near GOAT level.
 

Thavoiceofthevoiceless

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 26, 2019
Messages
44,974
Reputation
5,945
Daps
139,187
Reppin
The Voiceless Realm
Russ is in the top 15 conversation at the very least. He’s just not near GOAT level.

Nah. I can name you 15 QBs that are better than him. Plus it’s still too early in his career to give him that mantle. He’s never consistently put together a complete MVP type season as he always tapers off in the 2nd half of the season.
 

THE MACHINE

night owl
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
26,877
Reputation
6,520
Daps
104,353
Reppin
P.G. County
The first two sentences I disagree with. He'll be an all-timer when he hangs it up. He has a super bowl and was 1 play away from another. He will most likely have 400 TDs on a 3:1 ratio when he retires. He's been a starter 10 years and only has 1 losing season, and I think we all know he rushed his comeback this year.

While I agree with the 3rd sentence, there arent many QBs that fit that mold and I wouldnt say that eliminates them from being all-time greats. His book is still being written
 

Thavoiceofthevoiceless

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 26, 2019
Messages
44,974
Reputation
5,945
Daps
139,187
Reppin
The Voiceless Realm
The first two sentences I disagree with. He'll be an all-timer when he hangs it up. He has a super bowl and was 1 play away from another. He will most likely have 400 TDs on a 3:1 ratio when he retires. He's been a starter 10 years and only has 1 losing season, and I think we all know he rushed his comeback this year.

While I agree with the 3rd sentence, there arent many QBs that fit that mold and I wouldnt say that eliminates them from being all-time greats. His book is still being written

He’s not an All Time QB yet though which is the premise of his point.
 
Top