Russel Wilson >> RG3 >> Andrew Luck

[Kenny West]

The reason RG3 is better than Wilson or Luck is because unlike those two RG3 is consistent EVERY GAME. Every game this year he's been accurate, made good decisions, doesn't turn the ball over and made big plays. EVERY GAME. Even his "bad" games he preforms well, the receivers just fukk it up. He plays well even when Alfred Morris isn't doing well. (Alfred only has 10 TDs and he started every game) Russell is just catching on fire now. Luck plays well when he's feasting on wack secondaries.


RG3 preforms week in and week out, thats why I feel like we can beat any team when he's healthy. And he's been tested against by far the harder schedule.

 

[duncanthetall]

AFC South > AFC Bums (yes ravens too)

Rebuilding at 2-14 > Rebuilding 4-12

Colts > Bengals

Luck > Chad Pennington 2.0

And you know this, man

Only thing Luck did better his rookie year was passing yardage. Luck has lower comp percentage. Hella more INTS. Lower passer rating.

Andy > Carson Palmer 2.0

Keep that foolishness out ya mouth, ya bish

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

How does RG3 perform week in and week out when he's struggled to stay healthy?

Only thing Luck did better his rookie year was passing yardage. Luck has lower comp percentage. Hella more INTS. Lower passer rating.

Andy > Carson Palmer 2.0

Keep that foolishness out ya mouth, ya bish

The Bengals would throw their entire draft at the Colts right now for Luck.

 

[MooseMouthMthafuga]

He's earned ROY but I wouldn't take him long term over RG3 or Luck.

He seems like the dude that can excel in the right situation, not a guy who has to potential to do it regardless.

...sounds plausible

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

The reason RG3 is better than Wilson or Luck is because unlike those two RG3 is consistent EVERY GAME. Every game this year he's been accurate, made good decisions, doesn't turn the ball over and made big plays. EVERY GAME. Even his "bad" games he preforms well, the receivers just fukk it up. He plays well even when Alfred Morris isn't doing well. (Alfred only has 10 TDs and he started every game) Russell is just catching on fire now. Luck plays well when he's feasting on wack secondaries.


RG3 preforms week in and week out, thats why I feel like we can beat any team when he's healthy. And he's been tested against by far the harder schedule.

Don't you have to play every game before you can play consistent every game?

The fact that 2 of the skins biggest wins came after RG3 himself out of the game pretty much ended his Rookie of the year chances

 

[duncanthetall]

AFC South > AFC Bums (yes ravens too)

Rebuilding at 2-14 > Rebuilding 4-12

Colts > Bengals

Luck > Chad Pennington 2.0

And you know this, man

How does RG3 perform week in and week out when he's struggled to stay healthy?



The Bengals would throw their entire draft at the Colts right now for Luck.

You people really overrate the number 1 pick label. You idiots would probably throw a blank check at Sam Bradford. Or Stafford.

Don't believe the hype.

 

[Absolut]

seattle has played the 2nd most difficult schedule in regards to opposing teams defenses. its been WAY tougher than either the colts or redskins slate of defenses faced this year

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

Don't know about that particular order but Russel is the best out of the three at this point.

What a rookie class though, Russ should be ROY

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

Only thing Luck did better his rookie year was passing yardage. Luck has lower comp percentage. Hella more INTS. Lower passer rating.

Andy > Carson Palmer 2.0

Keep that foolishness out ya mouth, ya bish

Dalton Rookie Stats
3400 yards, 21 TD's, 58.1% completion percentage 45.8 QBR

Andrew Luck Rookie (still a week to play)
4100 Yards 26 TD's, 54 % completion percentage 64.6 QBR

you might want to reevaluate that statement

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

You people really overrate the number 1 pick label. You idiots would probably throw a blank check at Sam Bradford. Or Stafford.

Don't believe the hype.

at having to live in a world where Andy Dalton is your franchise QB.

Why are you even in here, we're discussing young QBs that have a chance to be elite.

 

[mastermind]

How does RG3 perform week in and week out when he's struggled to stay healthy?

missing one game is "struggling to stay healthy" now?

 

[duncanthetall]

nikkas using QBR like that shyts real life. Luck = Palmer 2.0

I've lived it.

I've seen it.

You'll be looking for a new QB in 5 years

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

missing one game is "struggling to stay healthy" now?

No.

missing one game, getting knocked out of two more is struggling to stay healthy.

 

[Brady-Carter]

RG3. Dude only has 4 Ints

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

nikkas using QBR like that shyts real life. Luck = Palmer 2.0

I've lived it.

I've seen it.

You'll be looking for a new QB in 5 years

So will the Bengals.